Children’s visual acuity tests at home: A prospective repeated measures study
Authors:
Preprint
Abstract
Background Home visual acuity tests could ease pressure on ophthalmic services by facilitating remote review of a variety of patients. Home tests may have further utility in giving service users frequent updates of vision outcomes during therapy, identifying vision problems in an asymptomatic population, and engaging stakeholders in therapy. The accuracy of home vision tests for children when completed without supervision from a professional is unknown. Methods Children attending outpatient clinics had their visual acuity measured 3 times in a randomised order at the same appointment. Once by a registered orthoptist as per standard clinical protocols, once by an orthoptist using a tablet-based visual acuity test (iSight Pro, Kay Pictures), and once by an unsupervised parent or carer using the tablet-based test. Results 42 children were recruited to the study. The mean age was 5.6 years (range 3.3 to 9.3 years). Median measurements (interquartile range) for clinical standard, orthoptic-led and parent/carer-led iSight visual acuity measurements were 0.155 (0.18), 0.180 (0.26), and 0.300 (0.33) respectively. The iSight app in the hands of parents/carers was significantly different from the standard of care measurements (P=0.009). In the hands of orthoptists, there was no significant difference between the iSight app and standard of care (P=0.551), nor was there significant difference between parents/carers using the app and orthoptists using the app (P=0.133). Conclusion This technique of unsupervised home visual acuity measures for children is not comparable to clinical measures and is unlikely to be valuable to clinical decision making and screening. Future work should focus on improving the technique through, for example, gamification of vision tests. What is already known on this topic?Children’s game visual acuity tests could improve things for hospital services and patients. The tablet-based tests are accurate when used by professionals to tests adults’ vision. What this study adds This study provides data about the accuracy of home tests when used by untrained parents or carers on their children. How this study might affect research, practice, or policy Current policy recommends apps home tests are not used to test children’s eyes for clinical decision-making purposes. Our data supports this policy and highlights the need for future research to focus on improving the tests. Synopsis / precis (“At a glance”) Visual acuity testing at home could improve patient care and reduce clinical visits, but data to show clinicians that they can rely upon the results in children are lacking. Our study shows the tests cannot be relied upon for clinical purposes. Improvements to the tests are required before they become useful and can be implemented into practice.Keywords
This publication has 12 references indexed in Scilit:
- Novel web application for self-assessment of distance visual acuity to support remote consultation: a real-world validation study in childrenBMJ Open Ophthalmology, 2021
- Clinical validation of a novel web-application for remote assessment of distance visual acuityEye, 2021
- Evaluation of a New Method to Track Changes in Vision at Home for Children Undergoing Amblyopia TreatmentBritish and Irish Orthoptic Journal, 2021
- Parental Home Vision Testing of Children During Covid-19 PandemicBritish and Irish Orthoptic Journal, 2021
- Testing Pediatric Acuity With an iPad: Validation of “Peekaboo Vision” in Malawi and the UKTranslational Vision Science & Technology, 2019
- Do the near computerised and non-computerised crowded Kay picture tests produce the same measure of visual acuity?British and Irish Orthoptic Journal, 2016
- An Educational Cartoon Accelerates Amblyopia Therapy and Improves Compliance, Especially among Children of ImmigrantsOphthalmology, 2012
- Randomised comparison of three tools for improving compliance with occlusion therapy: an educational cartoon story, a reward calendar, and an information leaflet for parentsGraefe's Archive for Clinical and Experimental Ophthalmology, 2012
- An audit of the outcome of amblyopia treatment: a retrospective analysis of 322 childrenBritish Journal of Ophthalmology, 2009
- Prevalence and risk factors for common vision problems in children: data from the ALSPAC studyBritish Journal of Ophthalmology, 2008