Conformity to popular, not average, opinions: Models, data, and evolution
Open Access
- 18 June 2026
- journal article
- Published by National Academy of Sciences in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
- Vol. 123 (25)
Abstract
In assessing how individuals in a network estimate a quantity, it is often assumed that they take an average or weighted average of the estimates of others they observe, as in the French–DeGroot learning model. However, individuals may actually copy clusters of similar opinions among their peers, a process that we call conformity. For example, if ten individuals estimate a quantity to be 0 and ten individuals guess 100, then although the average estimate is 50, one may conform by choosing either 0 or 100. Here, we a) extend a recent model of conformity to include both personal beliefs and social information, b) evaluate this model and two models of French–DeGroot averaging on human decision-making data, and c) simulate evolutionary dynamics of each model under different kinds of population structure, including static and adaptive networks. Under many of the conditions we analyze, the conformity model provides a significantly better fit to the data than either of the French–DeGroot models. In addition, evolutionary simulations reveal considerable differences among the models; for example, compared to the French–DeGroot models, the conformity model can produce faster shifts in populations toward “extreme” opinions—where individuals’ estimates of a quantity are either very large or very small—and can reduce individuals’ average estimation accuracy. These findings have implications for research on consensus formation, polarization, and wisdom of crowds.Keywords
Funding Information
- Santa Fe Institute (N/A)
- Morrison Institute for Population and Resource Studies, School of Humanities and Sciences, Stanford University (N/A)
- Center for Computational, Evolutionary and Human Genomics, Stanford University (N/A)
This publication has 54 references indexed in Scilit:
- Network effects on information acquisition by DeGroot updatersEconomic Theory, 2024
- A probabilistic linguistic opinion dynamics method based on the DeGroot model for emergency decision-making in response to COVID-19Computers & Industrial Engineering, 2022
- Static environments with limited resources select for multiple foraging strategies rather than conformityEcological Monographs, 2021
- Statistical Physics Of Opinion Formation: Is it a SPOOF?Comptes Rendus. Physique, 2019
- The when and who of social learning and conformist transmissionEvolution and Human Behavior, 2016
- Cultural evolution of cooperation: The interplay between forms of social learning and group selectionEvolution and Human Behavior, 2013
- Anticonformity or Independence?—Insights from Statistical PhysicsJournal of Statistical Physics, 2013
- Adaptive Social Learning Strategies in Temporally and Spatially Varying EnvironmentsHuman Nature, 2012
- Opinion Dynamics Driven by Various Ways of AveragingComputational Economics, 2005
- Models for cultural inheritance I. Group mean and within group variationTheoretical Population Biology, 1973