How smart was T. rex ? Testing claims of exceptional cognition in dinosaurs and the application of neuron count estimates in palaeontological research
Preprint
Abstract
Recent years have seen increasing scientific interest in whether neuron counts can act as correlates of diverse biological phenomena. Lately, Herculano-Houzel (2023) argued that fossil endocasts and comparative neurological data from extant sauropsids allow to reconstruct telencephalic neuron counts in Mesozoic dinosaurs and pterosaurs, which might act as proxies for behaviors and life history traits in these animals. According to this analysis, large theropods such as Tyrannosaurus rex were long-lived, exceptionally intelligent animals equipped with 'macaque- or baboon-like cognition' whereas sauropods as well as most ornithischian dinosaurs would have displayed significantly smaller brains and an ectothermic physiology. Besides challenging established views on Mesozoic dinosaur biology, these claims raise questions on whether neuron count estimates could benefit research on fossil animals in general. Here, we address these findings by revisiting Herculano-Houzel's (2023) work, identifying several crucial shortcomings regarding analysis and interpretation. We present revised estimates of encephalization and telencephalic neuron counts in dinosaurs, which we derive from phylogenetically informed modeling and an amended dataset of endocranial measurements. For large-bodied theropods in particular, we recover significantly lower neuron counts than previously proposed. Furthermore, we review the suitability of neurological variables such as neuron numbers and relative brain size to predict cognitive complexity, metabolic rate and life history traits in dinosaurs, coming to the conclusion that they are flawed proxies of these biological phenomena. Instead of relying on such neurological estimates when reconstructing Mesozoic dinosaur biology, we argue that integrative studies are needed to approach this complex subject.Keywords
All Related Versions
- Published version: The Anatomical Record, 307 (12), 3685.
This publication has 129 references indexed in Scilit:
- Could theropod dinosaurs have evolved to a human level of intelligence?Journal of Comparative Neurology, 2023
- Virtual endocasts of Clevosaurus brasiliensis and the tuatara: Rhynchocephalian neuroanatomy and the oldest endocranial record for LepidosauriaThe Anatomical Record, 2023
- High associative neuron numbers could drive cognitive performance in corvid speciesJournal of Comparative Neurology, 2022
- Palaeoneurology of the early cretaceous iguanodont Proa valdearinnoensis and its bearing on the parallel developments of cognitive abilities in theropod and ornithopod dinosaursJournal of Comparative Neurology, 2021
- Ontogenetic endocranial shape change in alligators and ostriches and implications for the development of the non‐avian dinosaur endocraniumThe Anatomical Record, 2020
- An Older and Exceptionally Large Adult Specimen of Tyrannosaurus rexThe Anatomical Record, 2019
- Longevity and sexual maturity vary across species with number of cortical neurons, and humans are no exceptionJournal of Comparative Neurology, 2018
- The Continuously Growing Central Nervous System of the Nile Crocodile (Crocodylus niloticus)The Anatomical Record, 2013
- Endocranial Anatomy of Lambeosaurine Hadrosaurids (Dinosauria: Ornithischia): A Sensorineural Perspective on Cranial Crest FunctionThe Anatomical Record, 2009
- Hind limb scaling in birds and other theropods: Implications for terrestrial locomotionJournal of Morphology, 1991