The Usefulness of the Supervisory Board Report in China
Authors:
- 11 September 2003
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Corporate Governance: An International Review
- Vol. 11 (4) , 308-321
Abstract
Chinese listed companies adopt a two‐tier board structure, a Board of Directors (BoD) and a Supervisory Board. They are also required to provide in their annual reports a supervisory board report (SBR). However, Congquin, a listed company, failed to issue a SBR in its 1998 annual report. This study specifically investigates the usefulness of the SBR by examining the stock market reaction to Congquin's SBR omission. The study also examines the Supervisory Board's reporting process and users’ perceived usefulness of the SBR through interviews with directors, supervisory board members and senior executives of 16 listed companies. Discussions were also held with financial analysts, regulatory officials and academics. Our event study suggests that the absence of the SBR in Congquin's 1998 annual report caused a negative market reaction suggesting that investors had considered the SBR and the Supervisory Board important and were discouraged by the problems manifested by the absence of the SBR. Our interviews reveal that the usefulness of the SBR depends on the role that the Supervisory Board plays in corporate governance. If the Supervisory Board is an honoured guest, a friendly advisor, or a censored watchdog, it is unlikely that the SBR will convey much useful information. By contrast, if the Supervisory Board acts as an independent watchdog, then the SBR would be useful. Given the fact that the Supervisory Board in most of the companies that participated in the interviews fell into the first three categories, there remains a strong need to improve the usefulness of the SBR and strengthen the functioning of the Supervisory Board.Keywords
This publication has 15 references indexed in Scilit:
- Building of a Corporate Governance System in Poland: initial experiencesCorporate Governance: An International Review, 2001
- Corporate Governance in a Third World Country with Particular Reference to NigeriaCorporate Governance: An International Review, 2001
- State Shareholding and the Value of China's FirmsSSRN Electronic Journal, 2001
- Developments in Corporate Governance in Central and Eastern EuropeCorporate Governance: An International Review, 2000
- On the Supposed Independence of Two‐tier Boards: formal structure and reality in the NetherlandsCorporate Governance: An International Review, 1999
- Boardroom Dynamics - Lessons in GovernanceCorporate Governance: An International Review, 1998
- The development of corporate governance in ChinaJournal of Contemporary China, 1998
- Corporate Governance in China's Listed CompaniesCorporate Governance: An International Review, 1995
- Competitiveness and Corporate GovernanceCorporate Governance: An International Review, 1994
- Measuring security price performanceJournal of Financial Economics, 1980