Assessing Modal Consistency in Operational Modal Analysis via Multialgorithm Identification and Consensus Metrics
Open Access
- 1 January 2026
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Structural Control and Health Monitoring
- Vol. 2026 (1) , 7665600
Abstract
The increasing number of ageing civil structures requiring continuous monitoring has highlighted the limitations of fully automated approaches to operational modal analysis (OMA), particularly in the presence of algorithm‐dependent variability and ambiguous stabilisation diagrams. In this context, the present paper proposes a modular, multialgorithm framework for assessing modal consistency and supporting decision‐making in OMA. Rather than relying on a single identification technique, the framework integrates multiple clustering strategies applied to stabilisation diagrams obtained via covariance‐driven stochastic subspace identification (Cov‐SSI). The approach explicitly acknowledges that different structural typologies, ranging from slender high‐rise buildings to massive civil and monumental structures, exhibit markedly different dynamic behaviours, for which no single algorithm can be expected to provide universally reliable results. To address this issue, clustering outputs from multiple algorithms are mapped into unified modal estimates, and a set of consensus metrics is employed to quantify the robustness and agreement of the identified modal parameters, including natural frequencies, damping ratios and mode shapes. The proposed methodology does not aim to replace expert judgement, but rather to provide a systematic, transparent and algorithm‐agnostic assessment of modal reliability, highlighting consistent modes as well as ambiguous or uncertain identifications. The framework is demonstrated through both a numerical benchmark and an experimental case study based on real accelerometric data from the Heritage Court Tower.Keywords
Funding Information
- Ministero dell’Istruzione, dell’Università e della Ricerca (FIS-2024-00457)
- Ministero dell’Istruzione, dell’Università e della Ricerca (CUPE53C25002310001)
- Università degli Studi dell'Aquila
This publication has 39 references indexed in Scilit:
- Generative adversarial networks review in earthquake-related engineering fieldsBulletin of Earthquake Engineering, 2023
- Automatic modal identification of bridges based on free vibration response and variational mode decomposition techniqueEngineering Structures, 2023
- Machine learning-based stochastic subspace identification method for structural modal parametersEngineering Structures, 2022
- Fully automated precise operational modal identificationEngineering Structures, 2021
- Modelling tensile tests on high strength S690 steel materials undergoing large deformationsEngineering Structures, 2019
- Appendix B: Operational Modal Testing of the Heritage Court Tower2015
- Introduction to Operational Modal Analysis2015
- Uncertainty propagation in SEA for structural–acoustic coupled systems with non-deterministic parametersJournal of Sound and Vibration, 2014
- Operational Modal Analysis of Civil Engineering Structures2014
- AUTONOMOUS STRUCTURAL HEALTH MONITORING—PART I: MODAL PARAMETER ESTIMATION AND TRACKINGMechanical Systems and Signal Processing, 2002