Effect of Subjective Preoperative Variables on Risk-Adjusted Assessment of Hospital Morbidity and Mortality
Authors:
- Mark E. CohenMCMark E. Cohen
- Karl Y. BilimoriaKBKarl Y. Bilimoria
- Clifford Y. KoCKClifford Y. Ko
- Karen RichardsKRKaren Richards
- Bruce Lee HallBHBruce Lee Hall
- 1 April 2009
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Annals of Surgery
- Vol. 249 (4) , 682-689
Abstract
To examine the influence of American Society of Anesthesiologists Physical Status Classification (ASA) and preoperative Functional Health Status (FHS) variables on risk-adjusted estimates of surgical quality and to assess whether classifications are inflated at some hospitals. ASA and FHS are influential in risk-adjusted comparisons of surgical quality. However, because ASA and FHS are subjective they can be inflated, making patients appear more ill than they actually are, and crediting hospitals for a sicker patient population. We identified 28,751 colorectal surgery patients at 170 hospitals participating in the American College of Surgeon's National Surgical Quality Improvement Program (ACS NSQIP) during 2006 to 2007. Logistic regression models were developed for morbidity and mortality with and without inclusion of ASA and FHS. Hospital quality rankings from the different models were compared. Morbidity and mortality rates were 24.3% and 3.9%, respectively. Percents of patients in ASA classes I through V were 3.3%, 46.4%, 41.5%,8.3%, and 0.7% and that were independent or partially or totally dependent were 89.2%, 7.2%, and 3.6%, respectively. Models that included ASA and FHS exhibited slightly better fit (Hosmer-Lemshow statistic) and discrimination(c-statistic) than models without both these variables, though magnitudes of differences were consistent with chance. There was inconsistent evidence for improper assignment of ASA and FHS. The small improvements in model quality when both ASA and FHS are present versus absent, suggest that they make a unique contribution to assessing severity of preoperative risk. With little indication that these subjective variables are subject to an important level of institutional bias, it is appropriate that they be used to assess risk-adjusted surgical quality. Periodic monitoring for inappropriate inflation of ASA status is warranted.Keywords
This publication has 17 references indexed in Scilit:
- Surgical outcomes research: a progression from performance audits, to assessment of administrative databases, to prospective risk-adjusted analysis – how far have we come?Current Opinion in Pediatrics, 2008
- How well do pediatric anesthesiologists agree when assigning ASA physical status classifications to their patients?1Pediatric Anesthesia, 2007
- Use of National Surgical Quality Improvement Program Data as a Catalyst for Quality ImprovementJournal of the American College of Surgeons, 2007
- Multivariable Predictors of Postoperative Cardiac Adverse Events after General and Vascular Surgery: Results from the Patient Safety in Surgery StudyJournal of the American College of Surgeons, 2007
- Postoperative complications and mortality in older patients having non‐cardiac surgery at three Melbourne teaching hospitalsMedical Journal of Australia, 2007
- The NSQIP: A new frontier in surgerySurgery, 2005
- Quality in Surgery: Current Issues for the FutureWorld Journal of Surgery, 2005
- The ASA Physical Status Classification: Inter-observer ConsistencyAnaesthesia and Intensive Care, 2002
- A survey of the ASA physical status classification: significant variation in allocation among Finnish anaesthesiologistsActa Anaesthesiologica Scandinavica, 1997
- An assessment of the consistency of ASA physical status classification allocationAnaesthesia, 1995