Conceptualizing Student Problem Dynamics Using Idiographic and Data-Driven Networks: A Feasibility Trial
Open Access
- 26 November 2025
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Cognitive Therapy and Research
- Vol. 50 (4) , 1-22
Abstract
Purpose: Nomothetic models of mood disorders often neglect individual heterogeneity. Idiographic network models could offer an alternative, but it is unclear whether subjective prior networks, data-driven networks, or networks that integrate both subjective information and empirical data should inform psychotherapy. Methods: We investigated the face validity of different networks, the utility, feasibility, and non-maleficence of implementing an ecological momentary assessment (EMA) protocol for network-informed treatment among 63 clinical psychology students. During the subjective prior network conceptualization , students explored personal issues, for which they generated EMA items and estimated the strength of the relationships between items. This information was later used to construct subjective prior networks serving as a prior for the PREMISE networks that integrate priors and longitudinal EMA data using Bayesian inference. In the EMA period , these items were prompted on their smartphones (7x/day for 15 days) to estimate data-driven networks. Finally, during the network feedback , trained therapists presented five networks ( temporal–unregularized, contemporaneous–unregularized , subjective prior , contemporaneous–Bayesian , contemporaneous–PREMISE) and subjects assessed their face validity. EMA response rates served as a feasibility-proxy and the Depression-Anxiety-Stress-Scale before and after EMA assessed mood non-maleficence. Results: The temporal–unregularized network had a significantly worse face validity than other networks ( contemporaneous–unregularized , subjective prior , contemporaneous–PREMISE ). The subjective prior network descriptively showed the highest face validity. Its conceptualization was also perceived significantly more useful than the EMA period and the network feedback. The subjects’ response rates were lower compared to previous studies. EMA did not affect mood significantly. Conclusions: The subjective prior network was perceived as descriptively most valid and its conceptualization most useful, suggesting it may serve as a subjectively valid fallback when data is limited. Due to its similar face validity and non-maleficence, the PREMISE method should be investigated in future clinical studies using EMA protocols with less prompts per day, but more assessment days. Lesson learned: Thorough subjective prior network conceptualizations could enhance adherence to EMA and to network-informed therapy interventions.Keywords
Funding Information
- Philipps-Universität Marburg
This publication has 95 references indexed in Scilit:
- A Dynamical Systems View of Psychiatric Disorders—TheoryJAMA Psychiatry, 2024
- A Dynamical Systems View of Psychiatric Disorders—Practical ImplicationsJAMA Psychiatry, 2024
- Ensemble learning: A surveyWIREs Data Mining and Knowledge Discovery, 2018
- Case conceptualization research in cognitive behavior therapy: A state of the science reviewJournal of Clinical Psychology, 2017
- A network theory of mental disordersWorld Psychiatry, 2017
- Case Mis‐Conceptualization in Psychological Treatment: An Enduring Clinical ProblemJournal of Clinical Psychology, 2017
- Measures Assessing the Quality of Case Conceptualization: A Systematic ReviewJournal of Clinical Psychology, 2016
- How important are the common factors in psychotherapy? An updateWorld Psychiatry, 2015
- WHAT IS THE THRESHOLD FOR A CLINICALLY RELEVANT EFFECT? THE CASE OF MAJOR DEPRESSIVE DISORDERSDepression and Anxiety, 2014
- PreferencesJournal of Clinical Psychology, 2010