Conversation analysis and extended pragma-dialectics in dialogue
Authors:
- Lotte van PoppelLPLotte van Poppel
- Keun Young SliedrechtKSKeun Young Sliedrecht
- Roosmaryn PilgramRPRoosmaryn Pilgram
Open Access
- 21 April 2026
- journal article
- Published by John Benjamins Publishing Company in Journal of Argumentation in Context
- Vol. 15 (2) , 107-134
Abstract
Both conversation analysis (CA) and extended pragma-dialectics (PD) share an interest in empirical, data-driven analysis of argumentative exchanges, a focus on sequential organization, and context-sensitivity. While cross-fertilization between CA and argumentation analysis in general took place, no full parallel analysis with CA and PD, let alone with extended PD was carried out. In this paper by CA and PD researchers, we compare how each approach interprets the same Dutch medical consultation and assess systematically how both approaches differ and complement each other. We will focus on disagreement management and doctor-patient decision-making. Our findings suggest that, despite the tensions, the combination of these approaches offers a more comprehensive understanding of the interactional dynamics of argumentation, shedding light on, e.g., the enactment of institutional roles, the normative consequences of turn-management, and varied facets of strategic maneuvering.Keywords
This publication has 36 references indexed in Scilit:
- Studying Controversies: A Path for Expansion of Argumentation TheoryArgumentation, 2025
- Demonstrating consensus in argumentative settings: Co-constructions in children’s peer discussionsEuropean Journal of Psychology of Education, 2024
- Quantifying Doctors’ Argumentation in General Practice Consultation Through Content Analysis: Measurement Development and Preliminary ResultsArgumentation, 2014
- Strategic Maneuvering in Treatment Decision-Making Discussions: Two Cases in PointArgumentation, 2011
- Argumentative Indicators in Discourse2007
- Analysing and evaluating problem-solving discussionsArgumentation, 1995
- Relevance reviewed: The case of argumentum ad hominemArgumentation, 1992
- Explaining in conversation: Towards an argument modelEuropean Journal of Social Psychology, 1992
- Confrontation in conversations: The adjacency pair as a tool of the descriptive component of a Pragma-dialectical analysisArgumentation, 1989
- Conversation, relevance, and argumentationArgumentation, 1989