Protocol‐based care: impact on roles and service delivery*
Authors:
- Jo Rycroft‐MaloneJRJo Rycroft‐Malone
- Marina FontenlaMFMarina Fontenla
- Debra BickDBDebra Bick
- Kate SeersKSKate Seers
- 31 October 2008
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice
- Vol. 14 (5) , 867-873
Abstract
Objective To evaluate the impact of protocol-based care on nursing roles, practice and service delivery. Design Case study evaluation informed by realistic evaluation methodology. Qualitative data collection methods were used including non-participant observation, post-observation interviews with nurses and patients, key informant interviews, tracking patient journeys and document review. Participants 141 participants took part including 73 nurses, midwives and health visitors, 4 allied health professionals, 20 doctors, 5 support staff and 39 patients. Settings Five sites were purposively sampled and included acute and primary care service provision. Findings As a mechanism for standardization, the use of protocol-based care approaches such as guidelines, care pathways, protocols and algorithms was patchy and dependent on contextual, professional and individual factors. Protocol-based care approaches were commonly used as checklists and for reference; nurses and doctors expressed concern that such use could lead to a ‘tick box mentality’ and restricted judgement. By using standardized care approaches nurses were taking on new tasks and developing skills beyond the traditional scope of practice including prescribing, diagnosing, ordering tests and sometimes deciding on treatments. The ability to perform these roles meant that they were able to run clinics or services independently. The extension of roles to incorporate prescribing, for example, meant that nurses were able to provide a more streamlined service for patients because they did not have to refer to doctors. In turn, it was reported that this reduced doctors' workload. Protocol-based care was viewed as a ‘nurses' thing’; however, some General Practitioners and junior doctors were using available standardized care approaches. Conclusions The potential of standardization was mediated by the patchy use of protocol-based care approaches and negative perceptions about standardization. Use of protocol-based care has the potential to impact on nurses' roles, increasing their autonomy and subsequently impacting on service delivery.Keywords
This publication has 15 references indexed in Scilit:
- Successful cardiovascular risk reduction in Type 2 diabetes by nurse‐led care using an open clinical algorithmDiabetic Medicine, 2006
- The challenges in adopting care pathways for the dying for use in care homesInternational Journal of Older People Nursing, 2006
- What's in a care pathway? Towards a cultural cartography of the new NHSSociology of Health & Illness, 2005
- Rules and guidelines in clinical practice: a qualitative study in operating theatres of doctors' and nurses' viewsQuality and Safety in Health Care, 2005
- Diffusion of Innovations in Service Organizations: Systematic Review and RecommendationsThe Milbank Quarterly, 2004
- The research agenda for protocol-based careNursing Standard, 2004
- Creation of a treatment protocol for nurse‐led management of anal fissureColorectal Disease, 2003
- Ingredients for change: revisiting a conceptual frameworkQuality and Safety in Health Care, 2002
- New Labour, Modernisation and the Medical Labour ProcessJournal of Social Policy, 2002
- Policy Emergence and Policy Convergence: The Case of ‘Scientific-Bureaucratic Medicine’ in the United States and United KingdomThe British Journal of Politics and International Relations, 2002