What constitutes appropriate peer review for interdisciplinary research?
Open Access
- 3 May 2016
- journal article
- Published by Springer Nature in Palgrave Communications
- Vol. 2 (1)
Abstract
How can interdisciplinary research proposals be more effectively assessed through peer review? A key issue is to characterize what constitutes appropriate peer review for interdisciplinary research. This is approached by considering four key elements on which evaluations of funding proposals are based: (1) the significance of the topic, (2) the importance and tractability of the research question, (3) the appropriateness of the methods and (4) the competence of the applicants, based on track record. Two major differences between disciplinary and interdisciplinary research emerge: (1) the unknowns that form the basis of research questions and (2) the methods employed. For peer review of interdisciplinary research proposals to become more effective, agreed criteria for assessment by peer review are required and this will only occur if interdisciplinarity is “organized” through colleges of peers and professional associations. This article is published as part of a collection on interdisciplinarity.Keywords
This publication has 12 references indexed in Scilit:
- Grant giving: Global funders to focus on interdisciplinarityNature, 2015
- Enhancing research collaborations: Three key management challengesResearch Policy, 2008
- What can the Swiss and Dutch trials tell us about the potential risks associated with heroin prescribing?Drug and Alcohol Review, 2003
- The Heroin Prescribing Debate: Integrating Science and PoliticsScience, 1999
- Provision of Diamorphine (Heroin) by Prescription for Drug DependencyCNS Drugs, 1999
- The ACT heroin trial: intellectual, practical and political challengesDrug and Alcohol Review, 1997
- Why? Who? How? Estimating numbers of illicit drug users: lessons from a case study from the Australian Capital TerritoryAustralian and New Zealand Journal of Public Health, 1996
- Becoming an ex-user: insights into the process and implications for treatment and policyDrug and Alcohol Review, 1994
- The ethics of experimental heroin maintenance.Journal of Medical Ethics, 1993
- Australian reports into drug use and the possibility of heroin maintenanceDrug and Alcohol Review, 1992