Are Water-Based Algorithms Still Adequate for Dose Calculation in Modern HDR Interventional Radiotherapy? A Review with Special Focus on 3D-Printed Applicators and Heterogeneous Materials
Authors:
- Enrico RosaEREnrico Rosa
- Bruno FiondaBFBruno Fionda
- Maria VaccaroMVMaria Vaccaro
- Valentina LancellottaVLValentina Lancellotta
- Elisa PlacidiElisa Placidi
- Maria Concetta La MiliaMMMaria Concetta La Milia
- Gabriele CiascaGCGabriele Ciasca
- Pierpaolo DragonettiPDPierpaolo Dragonetti
- Andre KariusAKAndre Karius
- Frank-André SiebertFSFrank-André Siebert
- Luca TagliaferriLTLuca Tagliaferri
- Marco De SpiritoMSMarco De Spirito
Open Access
Abstract
Background: High-dose-rate interventional radiotherapy (HDR IRT) relies on accurate dose calculations to ensure safe and effective treatment. The AAPM TG-43 formalism, based on homogeneous water assumptions, has long been the clinical standard, but the growing use of patient-specific applicators and heterogeneous materials challenges its accuracy. Materials and Methods: A literature narrative review was performed using PubMed and Scopus to identify studies comparing TG-43 and model-based dose calculation algorithms (MBDCAs), including deterministic methods (ACE, Acuros BV) and Monte Carlo simulations. Thirty-five studies were selected and qualitatively analyzed. Results: TG-43 yielded higher dose compared with MBDCAs, particularly in the presence of tissue heterogeneities, air gaps, shielding materials, and limited scatter conditions. Differences ranged from 2 to 5% in relatively homogeneous settings to more than 10–20% in complex geometries such as superficial mould treatments and head-and-neck IRT. Model-based approaches showed better agreement with Monte Carlo simulations and experimental measurements, especially in contact HDR IRT and applications involving 3D-printed applicators. Conclusion: While TG-43 remains clinically established and widely used, its limitations are increasingly evident in modern personalized HDR IRT. Model-based dose calculation algorithms provide greater dosimetric accuracy and should be progressively integrated into clinical practice, particularly in treatments involving significant heterogeneities.Keywords
This publication has 51 references indexed in Scilit:
- Beyond TG‑43: A PRISMA‐based systematic review on model‐based dose‐calculation algorithms in brachytherapyJournal of Applied Clinical Medical Physics, 2026
- Clinical test cases for commissioning, QA, and benchmarking of model‐based dose calculation algorithms in 1 ⁹ 2 Ir HDR gynecologic tandem and ring brachytherapyMedical Physics, 2026
- A graphical user interface for Monte Carlo dose calculations for brachytherapy with egs_brachyMedical Physics, 2025
- Retrospective assessment of HDR brachytherapy dose calculation methods in locally advanced cervical cancer patients: AcurosBV vs. AAPM TG43 formalismJournal of Applied Clinical Medical Physics, 2024
- Practical experience with initial quality assurance of a high dose rate brachytherapy grid‐based Boltzmann solver algorithmJournal of Applied Clinical Medical Physics, 2024
- The effect of vaginal cylinder inhomogeneity on the HDR brachytherapy dose calculations using Monte Carlo simulationsJournal of Applied Clinical Medical Physics, 2023
- AAPM WGDCAB Report 372: A joint AAPM, ESTRO, ABG, and ABS report on commissioning of model‐based dose calculation algorithms in brachytherapyMedical Physics, 2023
- A MC‐based anthropomorphic test case for commissioning model‐based dose calculation in interstitial breast 192‐Ir HDR brachytherapyMedical Physics, 2023
- A generic TG‐186 shielded applicator for commissioning model‐based dose calculation algorithms for high‐dose‐rate 192Ir brachytherapyMedical Physics, 2017
- Performance evaluation of a collapsed cone dose calculation algorithm forHDRIr‐192 ofAPBItreatmentsMedical Physics, 2017