Correcting for complexity: incorporating trait-numbers enhances the performance of EMMLi in investigating modularity
- 5 May 2026
- journal article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Evolution
- Vol. 80 (8) , 1868-1876
Abstract
Adams and Collyer (2019) evaluated the statistical performance of several approaches for quantifying morphological modularity and found that EMMLi had inflated type I error rates and a bias toward more complex models compared to the Covariance Ratio (CR) approach. They suggested that this may have been at least partly driven by the fact that AICc values from EMMLi do not incorporate trait numbers, but this was not verified. Here, I present a performance analysis of a trait-number corrected EMMLi approach (“EMMLip”), showing that this ameliorates rates of false discovery and produces conservative results that favor less complex models. The corrected EMMLi approach was effective at differentiating models of modularity with varying between- and within-module covariation especially when effect size or dataset size were sufficiently large. While CR tests remained more effective at specifically detecting overall modularity, I found that CR tests are sensitive to varying within/between module covariation, and in some cases had inflated model misspecification between 2- and 3-module hypotheses. With this minor correction (albeit incomplete), the combination of EMMLip and CR tests becomes the best available toolkit for detecting and contrasting modularity hypotheses. This toolkit is however still imperfect, and I discuss future avenues for improvements.Keywords
Funding Information
- National Science Foundation (NSF-DEB-#2135927)
This publication has 36 references indexed in Scilit:
- Correlated evolution of beak and braincase morphology is present only in select bird cladesJournal of Morphology, 2024
- Adaptive radiation despite conserved modularity patterns in San Salvador Island Cyprinodon pupfishes and their hybridsEvolutionary Journal of the Linnean Society, 2024
- Disentangling Mechanical and Sensory Modules in the Radiation of Noctilionoid BatsThe American Naturalist, 2023
- Simultaneous integration and modularity underlie the exceptional body shape diversification of characiform fishesEvolution, 2022
- Phenotypic integration in the carnivoran backbone and the evolution of functional differentiation in metameric structuresEvolution Letters, 2021
- Modularity promotes morphological divergence in ray-finned fishesScientific Reports, 2018
- Shape Covariation (or the Lack Thereof) Between Vertebrae and Other Skeletal Traits in Felids: The Whole is Not Always Greater than the Sum of PartsEvolutionary Biology, 2018
- Developmental origins of mosaic evolution in the avian craniumProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2017
- Methods for Studying Morphological Integration and ModularityThe Paleontological Society Papers, 2010
- Modern Applied Statistics with S2002