Uncertainties in the selection of applicants for medical school
- 17 August 2007
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Springer Nature in Advances in Health Sciences Education
- Vol. 12 (4) , 509-521
Abstract
Decisions about admissions to medical school are based on assessments of the applicants’ cognitive achievements and non-cognitive traits. Admission criteria are expected to be fair, transparent, evidence-based and legally defensible. However, unlike cognitive criteria, which are highly reliable and moderately valid, the reliability and validity of the non-cognitive criteria are low or uncertain. Their uncertain predictive value is due not only to their limited validity, but also to the unknown prevalence of the desirable non-cognitive traits in the applicants’ pool. Consequently, the use of non-cognitive admission criteria inevitably leads to rejection of an unknown proportion of applicants who have a desirable trait and selection of applicants who lack this trait. We propose that, rather than using non-cognitive admission criteria, admission officers should assist prospective applicants to make informed decisions based on a reflective self-appraisal whether or not to apply to medical school. To this end, medical schools should disseminate information on the strains of medical training and practice, the frequency of medical errors and the most common causes of dissatisfaction and burn-out among practicing physicians. Such information may improve the self-selection process and thereby enrich the applicants’ pool for individuals with appropriate motivation. The final selection of medical students may then be based either on past academic achievements, or on a lottery, or on various combinations thereof.Keywords
This publication has 48 references indexed in Scilit:
- Effectiveness of medical school admissions criteria in predicting residency ranking four years laterMedical Education, 2006
- Admissions processes for five year medical courses at English schools: reviewBMJ, 2006
- Validity Of Admissions Measures in Predicting Performance Outcomes: A Comparison of Those Who Were and Were not Accepted at McMasterTeaching and Learning in Medicine, 2002
- Medical school applicantsʼ essays as predictors of primary care career choiceAcademic Medicine, 1996
- A structured panel interview and group exercise in the selection of medical studentsMedical Education, 1995
- Retention of interviewing skills learned by first‐year medical students: a longitudinal studyMedical Education, 1992
- The influence of applicantsʼ gender on medical school interviewsAcademic Medicine, 1990
- Demographic variables in medical school admissionAcademic Medicine, 1990
- Selecting candidates for a medical school: an evaluation of a selection model based on cognitive and personality predictorsMedical Education, 1988
- Empathy: Historic and Current Conceptualizations, Measurement, and a Cognitive Theoretical PerspectiveHuman Development, 1975