This chapter assesses variants of abortion exceptionalism, that is, the over-regulation of abortion as a healthcare service, in what are considered economically developed, politically stable and liberal democracies, i.e. ‘high-income countries’. Comparing countries’ regulations against criteria from guidelines on abortion care issued by the World Health Organisation (WHO) in 2022, the chapter argues that exceptionalism is prevalent even among these countries and that it comes in different variants. Abortion regulations in 37 high-income countries, including three with 23 sub-national regions combined, making a total of 57 jurisdictions, are assessed on different dimensions against the WHO criteria using the Global Abortion Policies Database. Mapping the regulatory landscape in settings generally expected to have well developed frameworks respecting international human rights obligations demonstrates that exceptionalism persists. Furthermore, the analysis contributes a comparative perspective within the policy field of abortion, which reveals the differential focus of abortion exceptionalism on varied aspects of abortion policy among these countries.