Creating an archival infrastructure: a comprehensive review of the evidence base for mathematics teacher affect and practices instruments
Open Access
- 20 August 2026
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Mathematics Teacher Education
- p. 1-43
Abstract
This study seeks to create an archival infrastructure documenting the status of mathematics teacher education affective and practice-focused instruments at a recent point in time through a literature synthesis. We searched 24 mathematics education journals over a recent 20-year period to identify relevant quantitative instruments. From the initial 2286 articles identified, we focused on a set of 164 instruments with some validity, reliability, or fairness evidence to describe: the different categories of constructs being measured; the different types of instrument present; instruments with explicit attention to equity; the sources of validity, reliability, and fairness evidence; and patterns in sources of validity, reliability, and fairness by instrument type. We found that the majority of the instruments identified were focused on affective characteristics of teachers and utilized questionnaires to collect data from teachers. Almost half of those identified affective instruments were focused on teaching (e.g., beliefs about teaching and learning mathematics). We identified 48 of the 164 instruments focused on teachers’ practices, with the majority being observational instruments of teachers’ classroom practice. Finally, we found that reliability evidence was most prevalent, followed by evidence focused on test content. It was much less common for authors to provide evidence related to consequences of testing or fairness. There were different patterns in evidence provided for different types of instruments. We describe implications for instrument users and developers as we seek to develop a robust set of quantitative instruments in the field of mathematics teacher education.Keywords
Funding Information
- Southern Methodist University
This publication has 103 references indexed in Scilit:
- Introduction to PRISMA 2020 and implications for research synthesis methodologistsResearch Synthesis Methods, 2021
- Agency–structure dynamics in an indigenous mathematics education community in times of an existential crisis in educationEducational Studies in Mathematics, 2021
- Understanding (Dis)Agreement in Student Ratings of Teaching and the Quality of the Learning Environment2021
- Sociopolitical Dimensions of Mathematics Education2018
- Introducing an observational measure of standards-based mathematics teaching practices: Evidence of validity and score reliabilityEducational Studies in Mathematics, 2013
- An Analysis of Instruments that Measure the Quality of Mathematics Teaching in Early ChildhoodEarly Childhood Education Journal, 2008
- Surveying primary teachers about compulsory numeracy testing: Combining factor analysis with rasch analysisMathematics Education Research Journal, 2006
- Going Beyond Belief Systems: Exploring a Model for the Social Influence on Mathematics Teacher BeliefsEducational Studies in Mathematics, 2006
- Undergraduates' attitudes and beliefs about subject matter and pedagogy measured periodically in a reform-based mathematics and science teacher preparation programJournal of Research in Science Teaching, 2002
- Internal Consistency of Tests: Analyses Old and NewPsychometrika, 1988