Returning aggregate research results to participants: a scoping review of current practices, preferences and challenges
Open Access
Abstract
Objectives: To synthesise the current evidence about practices, preferences and challenges related to returning aggregate research results to participants, with implications for public health, health equity and policy development. Design: Scoping review conducted in accordance with the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses Extension for Scoping Reviews framework. Data sources: Four electronic databases—PubMed (National Library of Medicine), Excerpta Medica Database (Elsevier), Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature (Elton B. Stephens CO(mpany)) and Cochrane Library (Wiley)—were from inception to February 2025. Eligibility criteria: English-language, peer-reviewed articles reporting practices or preferences for returning aggregate clinical research results to participants. Studies reporting only individual/incidental findings, opinion pieces and non-original research were excluded. Data extraction and synthesis: Two reviewers independently screened studies and extracted data. Study quality was assessed using a modified Oxford Centre for Evidence-Based Medicine scale. Thematic synthesis identified patterns in dissemination methods, participant preferences and implementation barriers. Results: Of 272 articles screened, 12 published between 2002 and 2019 were included. They employed cross-sectional, qualitative and mixed-methods design across North America, Europe, Africa and Australia. Half focused on cancer; others addressed malaria, autism, hypothyroidism, HIV prevention and preterm labour. Most (8/12) included patients; others also included researchers, caregivers or mixed stakeholders. Participants were predominantly middle-aged or older, female and well-educated. Only two studies assessed literacy, both using unvalidated self-reports. Eight studies explored preferences without returning results; four implemented disseminations via mailed reports, printed summaries, in-person discussions or digital platforms. Participants favoured mailed letters and face-to-face meetings over online methods. Six themes emerged: receiving results as respect; preference for personalised, timely formats; importance of cultural tailoring; emotional and ethical considerations; institutional barriers; and community engagement as a facilitator. Conclusions: Returning aggregate research results to participants is ethically supported and strongly desired yet rarely practised. Bridging this gap requires clearer policy guidance, institutional support and equity-focused dissemination strategies. Health systems and researchers should adopt scalable, participant-centred approaches to fulfil ethical obligations and strengthen public trust in science.Keywords
Funding Information
- American Society of Nephrology and Kidney Cure’s Harold Amos Medical Faculty Development Award
- National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases (K08DK132511)
- National Institutes of Health’s National Library of Medicine (R01LM009886)
- National Institutes of Health’s National Library of Medicine (R01LM014344)
- National Institutes of Health’s National Library of Medicine (R01LM014573)
- National Institutes of Health’s National Library of Medicine (T15LM007079)
- National Center for Advancing Clinical and Translational Science (UL1TR001873)
This publication has 46 references indexed in Scilit:
- Assessing Internet access and use in a medically underserved population: implications for providing enhanced health information servicesHealth Information and Libraries Journal, 2011
- Opinions and intentions of parents of an autistic child toward genetic research results: two typical profilesEuropean Journal of Human Genetics, 2011
- Disclosure of individual genetic data to research participants: the debate reconsideredTrends in Genetics, 2011
- Return of Research Results: General Principles and International PerspectivesJournal of Law, Medicine & Ethics, 2011
- Public and Biobank Participant Attitudes toward Genetic Research Participation and Data SharingPublic Health Genomics, 2010
- Communicating the Results of Clinical Research to Participants: Attitudes, Practices, and Future DirectionsPLOS Medicine, 2008
- The return of research results to participants: Pilot questionnaire of adolescents and parents of children with cancerPediatric Blood & Cancer, 2007
- Disclosure of research results to research participants: A pilot study of the needs and attitudes of adolescents and parentsPaediatrics & Child Health, 2005
- Offering to Return Results to Research Participants: Attitudes and Needs of Principal Investigators in the Children's Oncology GroupJournal of Pediatric Hematology/Oncology, 2003
- Informing Study Participants of Research Results: An Ethical ImperativeIRB: Ethics & Human Research, 2003