Tracking SARS-CoV-2 variants of concern in wastewater: an assessment of nine computational tools using simulated genomic data
Authors:
- Steven G. SutcliffeSSSteven G. Sutcliffe
- Susanne A. KraemerSKSusanne A. Kraemer
- Isaac EllmenIEIsaac Ellmen
- Jennifer J. KnappJKJennifer J. Knapp
- Alyssa K. OvertonAOAlyssa K. Overton
- Delaney NashDNDelaney Nash
- Jozef I. NissimovJozef I. Nissimov
- Trevor C. CharlesTCTrevor C. Charles
- David DreifussDDDavid Dreifuss
- Ivan TopolskyITIvan Topolsky
- Lara FuhrmannLFLara Fuhrmann
Preprint
Abstract
Wastewater-based surveillance (WBS) is an important epidemiological and public health tool for tracking pathogens across the scale of a building, neighbourhood, city, or region. WBS gained widespread adoption globally during the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic for estimating community infection levels by qPCR. Sequencing pathogen genes or genomes from wastewater adds information about pathogen genetic diversity which can be used to identify viral lineages (including variants of concern) that are circulating in a local population. Capturing the genetic diversity by WBS sequencing is not trivial, as wastewater samples often contain a diverse mixture of viral lineages with real mutations and sequencing errors, which must be deconvoluted computationally from short sequencing reads. In this study we assess nine different computational tools that have recently been developed to address this challenge. We simulated 100 wastewater sequence samples consisting of SARS-CoV-2 BA.1, BA.2, and Delta lineages, in various mixtures, as well as a Delta-Omicron recombinant and a synthetic “novel” lineage. Most tools performed well in identifying the true lineages present and estimating their relative abundances, and were generally robust to variation in sequencing depth and read length. While many tools identified lineages present down to 1% frequency, results were more reliable above a 5% threshold. The presence of an unknown synthetic lineage, which represents an unclassified SARS-CoV-2 lineage, increases the error in relative abundance estimates of other lineages, but the magnitude of this effect was small for most tools. The tools also varied in how they labelled novel synthetic lineages and recombinants. While our simulated dataset represents just one of many possible use cases for these methods, we hope it helps users understand potential sources of noise or bias in wastewater sequencing data and to appreciate the commonalities and differences across methods.Keywords
All Related Versions
- Published version: Microbial Genomics, 10 (5).
This publication has 52 references indexed in Scilit:
- Detection of Novel Coronavirus by RT-PCR in Stool Specimen from Asymptomatic Child, ChinaEmerging Infectious Diseases, 2020
- Prolonged presence of SARS-CoV-2 viral RNA in faecal samplesThe Lancet Gastroenterology & Hepatology, 2020
- The presence of SARS‐CoV‐2 RNA in the feces of COVID‐19 patientsJournal of Medical Virology, 2020
- Virological assessment of hospitalized patients with COVID-2019Nature, 2020
- Wastewater-based epidemiology biomarkers: Past, present and futureTrAC Trends in Analytical Chemistry, 2018
- Simulating Illumina metagenomic data with InSilicoSeqBioinformatics, 2018
- SeqKit: A Cross-Platform and Ultrafast Toolkit for FASTA/Q File ManipulationPLOS ONE, 2016
- Near-optimal probabilistic RNA-seq quantificationNature Biotechnology, 2016
- Emerging investigators series: the source and fate of pandemic viruses in the urban water cycleEnvironmental Science: Water Research & Technology, 2015
- ShoRAH: estimating the genetic diversity of a mixed sample from next-generation sequencing dataBMC Bioinformatics, 2011