Comparing Ocean Surface Boundary Vertical Mixing Schemes Including Langmuir Turbulence
Open Access
- 15 November 2019
- journal article
- research article
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Advances in Modeling Earth Systems
- Vol. 11 (11) , 3545-3592
Abstract
Six recent Langmuir turbulence parameterization schemes and five traditional schemes are implemented in a common single‐column modeling framework and consistently compared. These schemes are tested in scenarios versus matched large eddy simulations, across the globe with realistic forcing (JRA55‐do, WAVEWATCH‐III simulated waves) and initial conditions (Argo), and under realistic conditions as observed at ocean moorings. Traditional non‐Langmuir schemes systematically underpredict large eddy simulation vertical mixing under weak convective forcing, while Langmuir schemes vary in accuracy. Under global, realistic forcing Langmuir schemes produce 6% (−1% to 14% for 90% confidence) or 5.2 m (−0.2 m to 17.4 m for 90% confidence) deeper monthly mean mixed layer depths than their non‐Langmuir counterparts, with the greatest differences in extratropical regions, especially the Southern Ocean in austral summer. Discrepancies among Langmuir schemes are large (15% in mixed layer depth standard deviation over the mean): largest under wave‐driven turbulence with stabilizing buoyancy forcing, next largest under strongly wave‐driven conditions with weak buoyancy forcing, and agreeing during strong convective forcing. Non‐Langmuir schemes disagree with each other to a lesser extent, with a similar ordering. Langmuir discrepancies obscure a cross‐scheme estimate of the Langmuir effect magnitude under realistic forcing, highlighting limited understanding and numerical deficiencies. Maps of the regions and seasons where the greatest discrepancies occur are provided to guide further studies and observations.Keywords
This publication has 125 references indexed in Scilit:
- Inhibited upper ocean restratification in nonequilibrium swell conditionsGeophysical Research Letters, 2013
- First air‐sea flux mooring measurements in the Southern OceanGeophysical Research Letters, 2012
- On the Existence of Water Turbulence Induced by Nonbreaking Surface WavesJournal of Physical Oceanography, 2009
- Significance of Langmuir circulation in upper ocean mixing: Comparison of observations and simulationsGeophysical Research Letters, 2009
- Mixed layer depth over the global ocean: An examination of profile data and a profile‐based climatologyJournal of Geophysical Research: Oceans, 2004
- Wave‐induced mixing in the upper ocean: Distribution and application to a global ocean circulation modelGeophysical Research Letters, 2004
- Wind‐driven internal waves and Langmuir circulations in a numerical ocean model of the southern Baltic SeaJournal of Geophysical Research: Oceans, 2002
- Comparative Analysis of Four Second-Moment Turbulence Closure Models for the Oceanic Mixed LayerJournal of Physical Oceanography, 2001
- Oceanic vertical mixing: A review and a model with a nonlocal boundary layer parameterizationReviews of Geophysics, 1994
- Development of a turbulence closure model for geophysical fluid problemsReviews of Geophysics, 1982