Stakeholder Criteria for Trust in Artificial Intelligence–Based Computer Perception Tools in Health Care: Qualitative Interview Study (Preprint)
Authors:
- Ansh RaiARAnsh Rai
- Meghan E HurleyMHMeghan E Hurley
- John HerringtonJHJohn Herrington
- Eric A StorchESEric A Storch
- Casey J ZampellaCZCasey J Zampella
- Julia Parrish-MorrisJPJulia Parrish-Morris
- Anika SonigASAnika Sonig
- Gabriel LázAro-MuñoZGLGabriel LázAro-MuñoZ
- Kristin Kostick-QuenetKKKristin Kostick-Quenet
Preprint
- 11 June 2025
- preprint
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Preprints
Abstract
BACKGROUND Computer perception (CP) technologies hold significant promise for advancing precision mental health care systems, given their ability to leverage algorithmic analysis of continuous, passive sensing data from wearables and smartphones (eg, behavioral activity, geolocation, vocal features, and ambient environmental data) to infer clinically meaningful behavioral and physiological states. However, successful implementation critically depends on cultivating well-founded stakeholder trust. OBJECTIVE This study aims to investigate, across adolescents, caregivers, clinicians, and developers, the contingencies under which CP technologies are deemed trustworthy in health care. METHODS We conducted 80 semistructured interviews with a purposive sample of adolescents (n=20) diagnosed with autism, Tourette syndrome, anxiety, obsessive-compulsive disorder, or attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder and their caregivers (n=20); practicing clinicians across psychiatry, psychology, and pediatrics (n=20); and CP system developers (n=20). Interview transcripts were coded by 2 independent coders and analyzed using multistage, inductive thematic content analysis to identify prominent themes. RESULTS Across stakeholder groups, 5 core criteria emerged as prerequisites for trust in CP outputs: (1) epistemic alignment—consistency between system outputs, personal experience, and existing diagnostic frameworks; (2) demonstrable rigor—training on representative data and validation in real-world contexts; (3) explainability—transparent communication of input variables, thresholds, and decision logic; (4) sensitivity to complexity—the capacity to accommodate heterogeneity and comorbidity in symptom expression; and (5) a nonsubstitutive role—technologies must augment, rather than supplant, clinical judgment. A novel and cautionary finding was that epistemic alignment—whether outputs affirmed participants’ preexisting beliefs, diagnostic expectations, or internal states—was a dominant factor in determining whether the tool was perceived as trustworthy. Participants also expressed relational trust, placing confidence in CP systems based on endorsements from respected peers, academic institutions, or regulatory agencies. However, both trust strategies raise significant concerns: confirmation bias may lead users to overvalue outputs that align with their assumptions, while surrogate trust may be misapplied in the absence of robust performance validation. CONCLUSIONS This study advances empirical understanding of how trust is formed and calibrated around artificial intelligence–based CP technologies. While trust is commonly framed as a function of technical performance, our findings show that it is deeply shaped by cognitive heuristics, social relationships, and alignment with entrenched epistemologies. These dynamics can facilitate intuitive verification but may also constrain the transformative potential of CP systems by reinforcing existing beliefs. To address this, we recommend a dual strategy: (1) embedding CP tools within institutional frameworks that uphold rigorous validation, ethical oversight, and transparent design; and (2) providing clinicians with training and interface designs that support critical appraisal and minimize susceptibility to cognitive bias. Recalibrating trust to reflect actual system capacities—rather than familiarity or endorsement—is essential for ethically sound and clinically meaningful integration of CP technologies.Keywords
All Related Versions
- Published version: Journal of Medical Internet Research, 27, e78757.
This publication has 28 references indexed in Scilit:
- 'You have to put a lot of trust in me': autonomy, trust, and trustworthiness in the context of mobile apps for mental healthMedicine, Health Care and Philosophy, 2023
- AI in the hands of imperfect usersnpj Digital Medicine, 2022
- Digital Phenotyping for Mental Health: Reviewing the Challenges of Using Data to Monitor and Predict Mental Health ProblemsCurrent Psychiatry Reports, 2022
- The growing field of digital psychiatry: current evidence and the future of apps, social media, chatbots, and virtual realityWorld Psychiatry, 2021
- Data mining for health: staking out the ethical territory of digital phenotypingnpj Digital Medicine, 2018
- Needed Innovation in Digital Health and Smartphone Applications for Mental HealthJAMA Psychiatry, 2017
- Harnessing Smartphone-Based Digital Phenotyping to Enhance Behavioral and Mental HealthNeuropsychopharmacology, 2016
- A literature review of the anchoring effectThe Journal of Socio-Economics, 2011
- Confirmation bias: A ubiquitous phenomenon in many guises.Review of General Psychology, 1998
- Varieties of Confirmation Bias1995