Moral asymmetries and the semantics of "many"
Open Access
- 7 October 2015
- journal article
- Published by Linguistic Society of America in Semantics and Pragmatics
- Vol. 8, 13-1-45
Abstract
We present the results of four experiments concerning the evaluations people make of sentences involving many, showing that two sentences of the form many As are Bs and many As are Cs need not be equivalent when evaluated relative to a background in which B and C have the same cardinality and proportion to A, but in which B and C are predicates with opposite semantic and affective values. The data provide evidence that subjects lower the standard relevant to ascribe many for the more negatively valued predicate, and that judgments involving many are sensitive to moral considerations in a broad sense, namely to expectations involving a representation of the desirability as opposed to the mere probability of an outcome. We relate the results to similar semantic asymmetries discussed in the psychological literature, in particular to the Knobe effect and to framing effects. http://dx.doi.org/10.3765/sp.8.13 Supplementary materials, BibTeX infoKeywords
This publication has 19 references indexed in Scilit:
- Extensionality in natural language quantification: the case of many and fewLinguistics and Philosophy, 2014
- On Doing Things IntentionallyMind & Language, 2012
- The framing of risks and the communication of subjective probabilities for victimizationsQuality & Quantity, 2010
- The Pervasive Impact of Moral JudgmentMind & Language, 2009
- A Unified Account of Quantifer Perspective Effects in DiscourseDiscourse Processes, 2007
- Tactful or Doubtful?Psychological Science, 2006
- An Intensional Parametric Semantics For Vague QuantifiersLinguistics and Philosophy, 2000
- Prior expectation and the interpretation of natural language quantifiersThe European Journal of Cognitive Psychology, 1993
- A semantic characterization of natural language determinersLinguistics and Philosophy, 1986
- Grading, A Study in SemanticsPhilosophy of Science, 1944