When Rivalry Backfires: How Individual Skill and Risk of Status Loss Moderate the Effects of Rivalry on Performance
- 1 March 2026
- journal article
- Published by Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences (INFORMS) in Management Science
- Vol. 72 (3) , 2477-2496
Abstract
Existing rivalry research finds that people try harder and perform better when competing against their rivals. However, are there conditions under which rivalry can harm performance? We integrate rivalry theory with regulatory fit theory to propose two moderators of rivalry: individual skill and situational risk for status change. We test our predictions using data from software programming contests involving more than 4.6 million competitive encounters across 16,846 software developers (“coders”) to examine the causal effects of rivalry and the conditions under which it may backfire. We find that, on average, coders who are randomly assigned to compete against a field of competitors with whom they share a rivalrous history exhibit higher performance, above and beyond other established drivers of performance in competition. Importantly, however, this positive effect of rivalry is moderated by (1) coders’ skill level, such that rivalry is more beneficial for more skilled coders and is harmful for less skilled coders, and (2) coders’ risk of experiencing a status change, such that coders who face a possible status loss exhibit decreased performance when competing against rivals. Thus, we extend research on rivalry by revealing the conditions under which it can harm performance, which is vital to understanding its role in organizations. This paper was accepted by Sameer Srivastava, organizations. Supplemental Material: The online appendix and data files are available at https://doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.2023.00344 .Keywords
This publication has 86 references indexed in Scilit:
- Trash-talking: Competitive incivility motivates rivalry, performance, and unethical behaviorOrganizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 2018
- The spark that ignites: Mere exposure to rivals increases Machiavellianism and unethical behaviorJournal of Experimental Social Psychology, 2017
- Cheating to get ahead or to avoid falling behind? The effect of potential negative versus positive status change on unethical behaviorOrganizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 2016
- The optimal sorting of players in contests between groupsGames and Economic Behavior, 2011
- Holding your place: Reactions to the prospect of status gains and lossesJournal of Experimental Social Psychology, 2010
- Self-regulation and moral awareness among entrepreneursJournal of Business Venturing, 2009
- An examination of the factorial, construct, and predictive validity and utility of the regulatory focus at work scaleJournal of Organizational Behavior, 2008
- Does peer ability affect student achievement?Journal of Applied Econometrics, 2003
- Regulatory Fit and Resisting Temptation during Goal PursuitJournal of Experimental Social Psychology, 2002
- Regulatory Focus and Strategic Inclinations: Promotion and Prevention in Decision-MakingOrganizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 1997