Abstract
Humans exhibit various untutored behaviours that seem to echo the biology of ancestral species: infants clutch, and people globally have similar expression sets for elementary emotion; infants are uniquely facile at learning about ancestral dangers like snakes. Popularisers commonly collate this information under the umbrella of an inherited "collective consciousness," or DNA-based transmission memory/consciousness that leverages those terms in a technically different context. This review: distinguishes evidence from claims; conceptualizes untaught behaviour less as inherited memory and more as an outcome of genetically instructed predispositions, genetically constructed architectures and genetically conditioned prejudices that use input from the ongoing experiences of their consumers; and employs fossil, paleoenvironmental, and paleogenomic evidence to place a historical anchor on ancestral condition, frame limits of ancestral conditions' persistence, and impose a constraint upon narrative elaboration unique to what the animal data will support. It then assesses strong candidate(s) for inheriting ancestral experience, transgenerational epigenetic inheritance, highlighting the direct developmentally contingent input from maternal environment rather than inherited ancestral experiences in human transgenerational epigenetic transmission and assessing remaining disagreements in this arena in animal studies. It finally dissects those collective consciousness-related notions where each is more remote from a grounded gene-level story. Incorporating the logic of the four Tinbergen questions, a framework for conceptually isolating mechanism, history, function and development in a field prone to collapsing them emerges.