Auditing Scoring Architecture in Financial Capability Surveys: Monte Carlo Evidence and a Peruvian Workplace Case on Perceived Financial Freedom
Authors:
- Fabricio Miguel Moreno-MenéndezFMFabricio Miguel Moreno-Menéndez
- José Francisco Vía Y Rada-VittesJRJosé Francisco Vía Y Rada-Vittes
- Nataly Gabriela Solis-TapiaNSNataly Gabriela Solis-Tapia
- José Antonio Cuadros-EspinozaJCJosé Antonio Cuadros-Espinoza
- Elizabeth Beatriz Barzola-CapchaEBElizabeth Beatriz Barzola-Capcha
- Manuel Silva-InfantesMSManuel Silva-Infantes
- Mercedes Rosario Canchan-CasasMCMercedes Rosario Canchan-Casas
- Vicente González-PridaVicente González-Prida
- Sara Ricardina Zacarías-VallejosSZSara Ricardina Zacarías-Vallejos
Open Access
- 5 October 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by MDPI AG in Journal of Risk and Financial Management
- Vol. 19 (10) , 779
Abstract
Self-report financial surveys require auditable scoring as well as evidence that their items measure the intended constructs. This study combines a Peruvian workplace archive of 50 records with an independently reconstructed Monte Carlo experiment. The audit distinguishes archived categories, direct sums, a historical partial key and correction of all four explicit constraint items. Full correction changes the overall correlation from −0.081 to −0.331 (record-level permutation p = 0.01930), while perceived-financial-freedom alpha falls from 0.708 to 0.255. The archive contains only 20 distinct response patterns; a pattern-cluster sensitivity interval includes zero. Archived categories are not deterministic functions of the stored sums. The simulation evaluates 82,500 synthetic datasets across a 27-cell baseline and 28 targeted extension cells. It separates measurement-related displacement, protocol distortion and finite-sample error. At N = 150 and a latent correlation of 0.40, the empirical key-map scenario yields a joint correlation change of −0.158 and a paired interaction of −0.041 (MCSE 0.0020). Mean observed-target baseline coverage is 0.949 for corrected sums and 0.948 for direct categories; latent-target inclusion is a different diagnostic. The contribution is an operational audit combining software invariants, item and provenance checks, and conditional robustness assessment. Scoring repair and synthetic evidence do not validate the source instrument or establish a substantive financial-capability effect.Keywords
This publication has 41 references indexed in Scilit:
- Digital financial literacy and savings behavior: A comprehensive cross-country analysis of FinTech adoption patterns and economic outcomes across 12 nationsBorsa Istanbul Review, 2025
- Financial well‐being: An integrated framework, operationalization, and future research agendaJournal of Consumer Behaviour, 2024
- Financial Freedom Perception Scale (FFPS): Construction and validationJournal of Behavioral and Experimental Finance, 2024
- Digital financial literacy and financial well-beingFinance Research Letters, 2023
- Is it all about money honey? Analyzing and mapping financial well-being research and identifying future research agendaJournal of Business Research, 2022
- Consumer Financial Well-Being: Knowledge is Not EnoughJournal of Family and Economic Issues, 2019
- Using simulation studies to evaluate statistical methodsStatistics in Medicine, 2019
- Financial well-being: A conceptualization and research agendaJournal of Business Research, 2017
- On the Use, the Misuse, and the Very Limited Usefulness of Cronbach’s AlphaPsychometrika, 2009
- Dichotomizing continuous predictors in multiple regression: a bad ideaStatistics in Medicine, 2005