TESTING SUSTAINABILITY BY PROSPECTIVE AND RETROSPECTIVE DEMOGRAPHIC ANALYSES: EVALUATION FOR PALM LEAF HARVEST
Open Access
- 1 January 2007
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Ecological Applications
- Vol. 17 (1) , 118-128
Abstract
Harvesting nontimber forest products (NTFPs) is a major economic activity in tropical forests. As many NTFPs are overexploited, sustainability analyses are required to set harvest guidelines. Here we introduce and apply a new approach to evaluating sustainability, which combines prospective (elasticity) and retrospective (Life Table Response Experiments [LTRE]) demographic analyses of matrix population models. We relate the elasticity of vital rates (representing their importance for population growth rate, λ) to their contribution to harvest‐induced change in λ (“LTRE contribution”). When high‐elasticity vital rates have a low LTRE contribution, exploitation is potentially sustainable as negative effects for population growth are buffered. If the reverse is found, there is little scope for sustainability because crucial vital rates are affected. Our approach is less sensitive to chance fluctuations than the commonly used sustainability criterion of λ = 1.0, as it does not depend on the absolute value of λ. We applied this analysis to Geonoma deversa, a clustered forest understory palm. We studied three experimentally defoliated and control populations in a Bolivian rainforest during two years. Cutting all leaves of large ramets did not change mortality but strongly affected growth and reproduction. In spite of severe changes in some vital rates, population growth rate was not significantly reduced after defoliation. A literature review revealed that six other understory palms species responded very similarly to defoliation. The combination of LTRE contributions and elasticity analyses showed that low‐elasticity vital rates were mainly responsible for the defoliation‐induced change in λ for Geonoma deversa. For two other understory palms (Astrocaryum mexicanum and Chamaedorea radicalis) new demographic analyses yielded very similar results. For Geonoma, the LTRE contribution–elasticity relation strongly changed when we mimicked harvest damage. Adding 5% mortality to defoliated palms caused stronger change in λ, mainly due to changes in a high‐elasticity vital rate (survival). Therefore, harvest practices that involve stem killing are clearly unsustainable. Our results show that commercial leaf cutting in Geonoma deversa is potentially sustainable, and that this is likely the case for understory palms in general. Our approach to evaluating harvest sustainability can be applied to other NTFPs.Keywords
This publication has 39 references indexed in Scilit:
- Demography and life history of Geonoma orbignyana: An understory palm used as foliage in ColombiaForest Ecology and Management, 2005
- NON‐TIMBER FOREST PRODUCT EXTRACTION: EFFECTS OF HARVEST AND BROWSING ON AN UNDERSTORY PALMEcological Applications, 2004
- Harvesting of Geonoma macrostachys Mart. leaves for thatch: an exploration of sustainabilityForest Ecology and Management, 2002
- Effects of Variation on Harvest Limits for Nontimber Forest Species in MexicoConservation Biology, 2002
- A new method of growth analysis for plants that experience periodic losses of leaf massFunctional Ecology, 2001
- Integrating vital rate variability into perturbation analysis: an evaluation for matrix population models of six plant speciesJournal of Ecology, 2001
- Demography of the vegetable ivory palm Phytelephas seemannii in Colombia, and the impact of seed harvestingJournal of Applied Ecology, 1998
- Conservation and Management of a Threatened Madagascar Palm Species, Neodypsis decaryi , JumelleConservation Biology, 1996
- Approaches to Developing Sustainable Extraction Systems for Tropical Forest ProductsEcological Applications, 1995
- Finding Confidence Limits on Population Growth Rates: Three Real Examples RevisedEcology, 1994