Beyond Legal Pluralism: Reframing the Dynamic Interaction between Shariah and State Law in Contemporary Muslim Societies
Open Access
- 31 December 2025
- journal article
- Published by LPPM Universitas 45 Mataram in Journal of Contemporary Islamic Law and Studies
- Vol. 1 (1) , 28-41
Abstract
The discourse on legal pluralism has long been used to explain the coexistence of Shariah and state law in contemporary Muslim societies. However, existing approaches often remain descriptive, portraying this relationship as a static duality rather than a dynamic and evolving interaction. This study challenges conventional legal pluralism by proposing a reconceptualization of the relationship between Shariah and state law as a negotiated and adaptive legal interface shaped by socio-political, institutional, and epistemological forces. Employing a qualitative conceptual approach grounded in socio-legal theory and Islamic legal studies, this research develops a novel framework termed Dynamic Legal Interaction (DLI). The findings reveal that the interaction between Shariah and state law is not merely coexistence but a continuous process of translation, contestation, and integration, where authority is redistributed across religious institutions, state actors, and societal practices. This study advances a theoretical shift from pluralism as coexistence to pluralism as interactional governance, thereby offering a more nuanced understanding of legal hybridity in Muslim contexts. By reframing legal pluralism through a dynamic lens, this research contributes to global socio-legal scholarship and provides a transformative framework for analyzing the evolving role of Islamic law within modern state systems.Keywords
This publication has 22 references indexed in Scilit:
- A Realistic Theory of Law2017
- Using Local Culture to Further the Implementation of International Human Rights: The Receptor ApproachHuman Rights Quarterly, 2012
- Religion and Modern Society2011
- Sharīʿa2009
- What Is Islamic Law?Theory, Culture & Society, 2007
- The New Law and Economic Development2006
- Crime and Punishment in Islamic Law2006
- The Dynamics of Change and Continuity in Plural Legal OrdersThe Journal of Legal Pluralism and Unofficial Law, 2006
- Islam, Law, and Equality in Indonesia2003
- What is Legal Pluralism?The Journal of Legal Pluralism and Unofficial Law, 1986