Abstract
Associative learning, like many mature fields of behavioural science, is endowed with a nearly unfathomable wealth of empirical data. These arise from multiple experimental procedures and animal species. To assess any proposed theory of associative learning, decisions must be made about which behavioral phenomena to account for. However, there is currently no systematic approach to selecting observations within this body of evidence. Here, we propose benchmarks for theories of associative learning by organizing phenomena according to their robustness across experiments, their generality across procedural variations, domains, and species, and the degree to which they occur under broad but clearly specified circumstances. We queried the expert community for phenomena to be included, reviewed the relevant literature, classified the phenomena into four categories of robustness and generality, and compared our classification with a second survey of the expert community. We identified 92 benchmark phenomena, of which 21 are domain- and species-general, and 24 are species- and/or domain-specific but highly robust across procedures. Strikingly, some textbook phenomena that have motivated influential and general associative learning theories are not among these. The remaining 47 phenomena were either constrained to particular experimental procedures or of inconclusive generality. Some of their implementational boundary conditions appear to be informally known but were rarely investigated systematically. In summary, our review provides a comprehensive evaluation of the current evidence, which will support theory building while also re-focusing research into areas in which evidence is lacking.