The shadow side of empathy? Eliciting empathy in journalism and its potentially unintended side-effects on polarization
Open Access
- 16 June 2026
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journalism
Abstract
Journalistic reporting has increasingly adopted a more human-centered approach, often aiming to evoke empathy in the audience. This is because empathy is expected to bridge the gap between ‘us’ and ‘them,’ thereby fostering social cohesion. However, previous assessments of empathy-inducing journalism tend to fall short in two ways: first, they often rely on broad definitions of empathy, while current models suggest a dual-process model involving emotional and cognitive empathy. Second, they frequently overlook the motivated nature of empathy, meaning that whether individuals are motivated to empathize with others’ feelings may depend on the perceived norms of their ideological peers. This could potentially exacerbate, rather than reduce, societal divides in the form of polarization. In an online experiment ( N = 933), we examine how an empathy frame (vs a non-empathy frame) on the topic of Afghan refugees influences emotional and cognitive empathy, whether these responses are moderated by social group norms, and how they relate to polarization of affect, human rights attitudes, and policy support. We found no norm-driven polarization of emotional empathy after reading the stimulus. Instead, we observed a small positive direct effect of the empathy-frame on affect toward Afghan refugees, highlighting the benefits of using empathy inducing frames, even when communicating polarized issues.Keywords
This publication has 68 references indexed in Scilit:
- Perceptions of Afghan and Ukrainian refugees in EuropeActa Psychologica, 2024
- Partisan Motivated Empathy and Policy AttitudesPolitical Behavior, 2023
- Polarization about Human Rights: Political Orientation, Morality, and Belief in a Just WorldTrends in Psychology, 2023
- Polarization in attitudes towards refugees and migrants in the NetherlandsEuropean Journal of Social Psychology, 2021
- Affective polarization in multiparty systemsElectoral Studies, 2021
- Social Norms and the Labor Market2020
- Investigating the reliability and validity of the Multidimensional Emotional Empathy ScaleMeasurement, 2016
- Public support for Hispanic deportation in the United States: the effects of ethnic prejudice and perceptions of economic competition in a period of economic distressJournal of Population Research, 2012
- Intergroup contact in context: The mediating role of social norms and group-based perceptions on the contact–prejudice linkInternational Journal of Intercultural Relations, 2009
- Cognitive Empathy and Emotional Empathy in Human Behavior and EvolutionThe Psychological Record, 2006