Abstract
The aim of this paper was to provide commentary on one prevalent theme found in many of the articles within the current special issue: the notion of moving beyond a qualitative–quantitative divide using mixed methods to help navigate and/or reconcile this divide. This commentary highlights several key controversial issues in mixed methods literature within the social sciences in order to raise critical consciousness about such issues. We explore these distinct yet interrelated issues in the form of two central questions: what are mixed methods? And do mixed methods privilege post-positivism? As the field of sport and exercise psychology moves towards blurred genres in qualitative research (i.e. acknowledging a full range of paradigms, methods and strategies and the boundaries between them softened), such questions are important to raise and consider in order to advance critical dialogues on mixed methods within the field, allowing researchers to be more open, critical and reflexive. Our commentary concludes by offering some final reflections on mixed methods research in sport and exercise psychology in the light of these issues and questions.

This publication has 26 references indexed in Scilit: