Comparison of Fuzzy AHP and Fuzzy TOPSIS for Road Pavement Maintenance Prioritization: Methodological Exposition and Case Study
Authors:
Open Access
- 9 July 2015
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Hindawi Limited in Advances in Civil Engineering
- Vol. 2015, 1-17
Abstract
For road pavement maintenance and repairs prioritization, a multiattribute approach that compares fuzzy Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP) and fuzzy Technique for Order Preference by Ideal Situation (TOPSIS) is evaluated. The pavement distress data was collected through empirical condition surveys and rating by pavement experts. In comparison to the crisp AHP, the fuzzy AHP and fuzzy TOPSIS pairwise comparison techniques are considered to be more suitable for the subjective analysis of the pavement conditions for automated maintenance prioritization. From the case study results, four pavement maintenance objectives were determined as road safety, pavement surface preservation, road operational status and standards, and road aesthetics, with corresponding depreciating significance weights of. The top three maintenance functions were identified as Thin Hot Mix Asphalt (HMA) overlays, resurfacing and slurry seals, which were a result of pavement cracking, potholes, raveling, and patching, while the bottom three were cape seal, micro surfacing, and fog seal. The two methods gave nearly the same prioritization ranking. In general, the fuzzy AHP approach tended to overestimate the maintenance prioritization ranking as compared to the fuzzy TOPSIS.
Keywords
This publication has 24 references indexed in Scilit:
- Notes on Dependent Attributes in TOPSISProcedia Computer Science, 2014
- Evaluation of prioritization methods for effective pavement maintenance of urban roadsInternational Journal of Pavement Engineering, 2012
- Effects of increasing fuzziness on analytic hierarchy process for spatial multicriteria decision analysisComputers, Environment and Urban Systems, 2012
- Pavement Condition Assessment Using Fuzzy Logic Theory and Analytic Hierarchy ProcessJournal of Transportation Engineering, 2011
- Pavement Maintenance Prioritization Using Analytic Hierarchy ProcessTransportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board, 2009
- Analytic hierarchy process: An overview of applicationsEuropean Journal of Operational Research, 2006
- Deriving priorities from fuzzy pairwise comparison judgementsFuzzy Sets and Systems, 2003
- Current and Future Pavement Maintenance Prioritization Based on Rapid Visual Condition EvaluationJournal of Transportation Engineering, 2001
- Multicriteria analysis with fuzzy pairwise comparisonInternational Journal of Approximate Reasoning, 1999
- A scaling method for priorities in hierarchical structuresJournal of Mathematical Psychology, 1977