Data Deserts and Black Boxes: The Impact of Socio-Economic Status on Consumer Profiling
- 1 November 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences (INFORMS) in Management Science
- Vol. 70 (11) , 8003-8029
Abstract
Data brokers use black-box methods to profile and segment individuals for ad targeting, often with mixed success. We present evidence from 5 complementary field tests and 15 data brokers that differences in profiling accuracy and coverage for these attributes mainly depend on who is being profiled. Consumers who are better off—for example, those with higher incomes or living in affluent areas—are both more likely to be profiled and more likely to be profiled accurately. Occupational status (white-collar versus blue-collar jobs), race and ethnicity, gender, and household arrangements often affect the accuracy and likelihood of having profile information available, although this varies by country and whether we consider online or offline coverage of profile attributes. Our analyses suggest that successful consumer-background profiling can be linked to the scope of an individual’s digital footprint from how much time they spend online and the number of digital devices they own. Those who come from lower-income backgrounds have a narrower digital footprint, leading to a “data desert” for such individuals. Vendor characteristics, including differences in profiling methods, explain virtually none of the variation in profiling accuracy for our data, but explain variation in the likelihood of who is profiled. Vendor differences due to unique networks and partnerships also affect profiling outcomes indirectly due to differential access to individuals with different backgrounds. We discuss the implications of our findings for policy and marketing practice. This paper was accepted by David Simchi-Levi, marketing. Funding: Financial support from the National Science Foundation [CAREER Award 6923256] and an anonymous panel company is gratefully acknowledged. Supplemental Material: The web appendix and data files are available at https://doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.2023.4979 .Keywords
This publication has 26 references indexed in Scilit:
- If an Advertisement Runs Online And No One Sees It, Is It Still an Ad?Journal of Advertising Research, 2013
- Privacy and InnovationInnovation Policy and the Economy, 2012
- Can Health Care Information Technology Save Babies?Journal of Political Economy, 2011
- Bootstrap-Based Improvements for Inference with Clustered ErrorsReview of Economics and Statistics, 2008
- Internet adoption and usage patterns are different: Implications for the digital divideInformation Economics and Policy, 2008
- Digital inequality: A five country comparison using microdataSocial Science Research, 2007
- The Effect of Banner Advertising on Internet PurchasingJournal of Marketing Research, 2006
- The Role of the Management Sciences in Research on PersonalizationManagement Science, 2003
- The demand for deductibles in private health insuranceJournal of Econometrics, 1981
- Sample Selection Bias as a Specification ErrorEconometrica, 1979