Dissension in public evaluations of the police
Open Access
- 6 September 2013
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Policing and Society
- Vol. 25 (2) , 212-235
Abstract
The way in which police officers deal with the public has a profound and predominantly negative influence on how the police generally are viewed by the public. Tyler's theory of ‘procedural justice’ argues that if officers act with fairness and respect when interacting with the public, they can win legitimacy. This theory is however one sided; the process of interaction involves not only how the police behave, but also how members of the public perceive and interpret that behaviour. This article examines the perceptions and interpretations of police actions by 34 diverse focus groups in the ‘Black Country’ region of the West Midlands using a real-life videoed encounter between police officers and a suspected car thief. Whilst issues of fairness and respect surfaced repeatedly in these focus group discussions, there was also widespread dissension about how crucial phases of the encounter were perceived and appraised. Various participants drew attention to the same occurrences within the video clip to justify entirely contradictory evaluations. This demonstrates the problematic relationship between action, perception and approval. It poses an enormous practical problem for police officers in winning the trust and confidence of the public whom they encounter in the course of their duties, for there is no simple recipe for winning legitimacy.Keywords
This publication has 19 references indexed in Scilit:
- Procedural justice and professional policing in times of austerityCriminology & Criminal Justice, 2012
- Convergence, Not Divergence?: Trends and Trajectories in Public Contact and Confidence in the PoliceThe British Journal of Criminology, 2010
- “POLICE DON'T LIKE BLACK PEOPLE”: AFRICAN‐AMERICAN YOUNG MEN'S ACCUMULATED POLICE EXPERIENCES*Criminology & Public Policy, 2007
- Young Black Men and Urban Policing in the United StatesThe British Journal of Criminology, 2005
- Fall of the ‘Platonic Guardians’The British Journal of Criminology, 2005
- Policing and the Condition of EnglandMemory, Politics and Culture2003
- Race and attitudes toward the policeJournal of Criminal Justice, 2002
- Institutional Legitimacy, Procedural Justice, and Compliance with Supreme Court Decisions: A Question of CausalityLaw & Society Review, 1991
- Understandings of Justice: Institutional Legitimacy, Procedural Justice, and Political ToleranceLaw & Society Review, 1989
- Political Alienation and Public Satisfaction with Police ServicesThe Pacific Sociological Review, 1981