Evaluation of cultural competency in a South African cluster randomised controlled trial: lessons learned for trial reporting standards
Open Access
- 29 October 2022
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Trials
- Vol. 23 (1) , 1-9
Abstract
Background: Failure to consider relevant cultural, ethnic and diversity parameters (and the intersection between these parameters) during trial protocol development and trial conduct may negatively impact recruitment, intervention development and delivery, and participant adherence and retention, potentially reducing overall internal validity. This case study aimed to evaluate the utility and comparability between the 9-item Gibbs Framework to measure cultural competency and the GRIPP-2(Short Form (SF)) 5-point checklist to assess patient and public involvement in the context of a complex clinical trial conducted in an African setting. Methods: We identified and collated all relevant publications, source and procedural data related to the trial and integrated the documents into a dynamic trial timeline. Two independent investigators applied and scored the Gibbs Framework and the GRIPP-2(SF) checklist to the four publications arising from the trial, noting functionality and comparability between tools. Where cultural competency was not met, a third investigator screened all procedural and source data and identified if cultural competency had been achieved but not reported in the publications, or if the trial had not met appropriate cultural competency based on the documentation. Results: Application of the Gibbs Framework found that the trial scored ‘2’ for seven of the nine Gibbs items, indicating full cultural competency for those questions. The Framework indicated that the trial research question was not driven by the articulated needs of patients, and neither were patients, caregivers and clinical providers involved in the development of the intervention. Comparability with the GRIPP-2(SF) checklist showed that the Gibbs performed better on evaluation of partnerships with the community, identification of culturally competent data sources and target populations, and appointment of trial staff in an inclusive manner. Conclusions: Comprehensive evaluation of the trial’s cultural competency required scrutiny of both published manuscripts and source and procedural data, suggesting that there is a gap in current trial reporting standards with respect to cultural competence. Trial registration: PACTR201610001825403. Registered on 17 October 2016.Keywords
Funding Information
- UK Medical Research Council (MRC) Trials Methodology Research Partnership (MR/S014357/1)
- South African Medical Research Council
This publication has 17 references indexed in Scilit:
- Patient preferences for the integration of mental health counseling and chronic disease care in South AfricaPatient Preference and Adherence, 2018
- CONSORT-SPI 2018 Explanation and Elaboration: guidance for reporting social and psychological intervention trialsTrials, 2018
- Comparing dedicated and designated models of integrating mental health into chronic disease care: study protocol for a cluster randomized controlled trialTrials, 2018
- GRIPP2 reporting checklists: tools to improve reporting of patient and public involvement in researchBMJ, 2017
- Assessing the cultural competence of oral health research conducted with migrant childrenCommunity Dentistry and Oral Epidemiology, 2013
- SPIRIT 2013 explanation and elaboration: guidance for protocols of clinical trialsBMJ, 2013
- The role of community advisory boards in health research: Divergent views in the South African experienceSAHARA-J: Journal of Social Aspects of HIV/AIDS, 2010
- Debate on measures of outcomeJournal of Clinical Epidemiology, 2010
- A Fundamental Choice: Internal or External Evaluation?Evaluation Journal of Australasia, 2005
- Qualitative research: standards, challenges, and guidelinesThe Lancet, 2001