Synaptic output depends on the number of vesicle release sites, calcium influx during an action potential, and the coupling of calcium influx to a docked vesicle. Changes in any one of these properties could underlie synaptic plasticity. Here, we reveal that the baseline spatial organization of voltage-gated calcium channels (VGCCs) relative to the release machinery defines the capacity for presynaptic plasticity at broadly defined glutamate and GABA small central synapses. At glutamate synapses, VGCCs are evenly distributed to vesicle release sites and display a single VGCC-release site coupling relationship. By contrast, at GABA synapses, VGCCs are clustered around a fraction of release sites under basal conditions and release sites appear to be couple to multiple VGCCs. Challenging the two synapse types with chemical potentiation results in synaptic strengthening with different characteristics—a property that is conserved across species. While in both synapse types, activation of PKA results in an increase in the readily releasable pool of synaptic vesicles, Only at GABA synapses is this potentiation accompanied by an increase in release probability, which is reflected by both a dramatic reorganization or VGCCs in the AZ and physiological change between the coupling distance between calcium source and release site. Together, our findings identify baseline presynaptic nanoarchitecture as a key determinant of structural and functional plasticity, uncovering nanoscale VGCC reorganization as a fundamental mechanism controlling adaptive changes in neurotransmission.