Randomized Comparison of Universal and Targeted HIV Screening in the Emergency Department
- 1 November 2013
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in JAIDS Journal of Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndromes
- Vol. 64 (3) , 315-323
Abstract
Objective: Universal HIV screening is recommended but challenging to implement. Selectively targeting those at risk is thought to miss cases, but previous studies are limited by narrow risk criteria, incomplete implementation, and absence of direct comparisons. We hypothesized that targeted HIV screening, when fully implemented and using maximally broad risk criteria, could detect nearly as many cases as universal screening with many fewer tests. Methods: This single-center cluster-randomized trial compared universal and targeted patient selection for HIV screening in a lower prevalence urban emergency department. Patients were excluded for age (64 years), known HIV infection, or previous approach for HIV testing that day. Targeted screening was offered for any risk indicator identified from charts, staff referral, or self-disclosure. Universal screening was offered regardless of risk. Baseline seroprevalence was estimated from consecutive deidentified blood samples. Results: There were 9572 eligible visits during which the patient was approached. For universal screening, 40.8% (1915/4692) consented with 6 being newly diagnosed [0.31%, 95% confidence interval (CI): 0.13% to 0.65%]. For targeted screening, 37% (1813/4880) had no testing indication. Of the 3067 remaining, 47.4% (1454) consented with 3 being newly diagnosed (0.22%, 95% CI: 0.06% to 0.55%). Estimated seroprevalence was 0.36% (95% CI: 0.16% to 0.70%). Targeted screening had a higher proportion consenting (47.4% vs. 40.8%, P < 0.002), but a lower proportion of ED encounters with testing (29.7% vs. 40.7%, P < 0.002). Conclusions: Targeted screening, even when fully implemented with maximally permissive selection, offered no important increase in positivity rate or decrease in tests performed. Universal screening diagnosed more cases, because more were tested, despite a modestly lower consent rate.Keywords
This publication has 80 references indexed in Scilit:
- Can Computer-Based Feedback Improve Emergency Department Patient Uptake of Rapid HIV Screening?Annals of Emergency Medicine, 2011
- Using Nonrapid HIV Technology for Routine, Opt-out HIV Screening in a High-Volume Urban Emergency DepartmentAnnals of Emergency Medicine, 2011
- Rapid HIV Testing in a Southeastern Emergency Department Serving a Semiurban-Semirural Adolescent and Adult PopulationAnnals of Emergency Medicine, 2011
- Counselor- Versus Provider-Based HIV Screening in the Emergency Department: Results From the Universal Screening for HIV Infection in the Emergency Room (USHER) Randomized Controlled TrialAnnals of Emergency Medicine, 2011
- A Simple Method for Estimating the Prevalence of Undiagnosed HIV Infection in an Emergency DepartmentAnnals of Emergency Medicine, 2011
- Comparison of Missed Opportunities for Earlier HIV Diagnosis in 3 Geographically Proximate Emergency DepartmentsAnnals of Emergency Medicine, 2011
- Operational Methods of HIV Testing in Emergency Departments: A Systematic ReviewAnnals of Emergency Medicine, 2011
- Evaluation of pooled rapid HIV antibody screening of patients admitted to a San Diego HospitalJournal of Virological Methods, 2011
- Risk, reasons for refusal, and impact of counseling on consent among ED patients declining HIV screeningThe American Journal of Emergency Medicine, 2011
- Factors Associated with Refusal of Rapid HIV Testing in an Emergency DepartmentAIDS and Behavior, 2010