Exploring PE teachers’ ‘gut feelings’
Authors:
- 20 January 2014
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in European Physical Education Review
- Vol. 20 (2) , 199-214
Abstract
Research shows that teachers’ grading is influenced by non-achievement factors in addition to official criteria, such as knowledge and skills. Some grading criteria are internalised by the teacher, who is sometimes unable to verbalise the criteria used and refers to what is called a ‘gut feeling’. Therefore, transparency, validity and reliability are problematic. The aim of this study was to explore which criteria physical education teachers consider important when grading. Such an exploration makes it possible to discuss how the verbalised criteria and the value they are given by the teachers can be understood. Four Year 9 teachers at different Swedish compulsory schools were interviewed using Kelly’s Repertory Grid technique. Among the verbalised criteria, four themes were identified: motivation, knowledge and skills, self-confidence and interaction with others. The teachers sometimes had difficulties predicting which criteria had relevance to the grades given, and the criteria considered important by the teachers were not always reflected in the grade. The verbalised criteria revealed teachers using grades to encourage such student behaviours that helped them to handle the classroom situation and to facilitate students learning. To become cognisant of and develop their grading, methods to verbalise their individual grading criteria were needed, and Kelly’s Repertory Grid technique is one possible option. The results provide discussion points about reasons for the way teachers are grading.Keywords
This publication has 21 references indexed in Scilit:
- Understanding the pedagogic discourse of assessment in Physical EducationAsia-Pacific Journal of Health, Sport and Physical Education, 2011
- ‘I have my own picture of what the demands are ... ’: Grading in Swedish PEH — problems of validity, comparability and fairnessEuropean Physical Education Review, 2010
- Curriculum, pedagogy and assessment: three message systems of schooling and dimensions of quality physical educationSport, Education and Society, 2009
- Defining, acquiring and transacting cultural capital through assessment in physical educationEuropean Physical Education Review, 2009
- Symbolic capital in physical education and health: to be, to do or to know? That is the gendered questionSport, Education and Society, 2009
- Effects of student characteristics on grades in compulsory schoolEducational Research and Evaluation, 2009
- Discrepancies between school grades and test scores at individual and school level: effects of gender and family backgroundEducational Research and Evaluation, 2008
- Understanding and Improving Teachers' Classroom Assessment Decision Making: Implications for Theory and PracticeEducational Measurement: Issues and Practice, 2003
- Hodgepodge Grading: Endorsed by Students and Teachers AlikeApplied Measurement in Education, 1999
- Grading Practices and ValidityEducational Measurement: Issues and Practice, 1991