Abstract
Background/Objectives: Provider affect, preparedness and empathy may influence behaviour guidance in paediatric dentistry, but their measurement alongside observed clinical behaviour and child-level responses has not been systematically mapped. Methods: A protocol-registered scoping review followed JBI guidance and PRISMA-ScR. Nine databases and complementary sources were searched, and eligible primary reports were charted by study family. Measurement domains were coded as clinician-reported, physiological, independently observed, child-level or caregiver-level. Results: Thirty-three reports representing 32 study families met the criteria. Principal constructs were stress/anxiety/coping (n = 19), confidence/preparedness (n = 9) and empathy (n = 4). Twenty-five families (78.1%) used provider self-report alone; five included child-level measures or treatment-related endpoints, and one independently assessed clinician behaviour. No study family co-measured a provider construct, observed clinical behaviour and a child-level measure. Conclusions: Existing studies describe clinician experiences much more frequently than the actions taken during treatment. Integrating provider-state measures, observed chairside conduct and child responses within the same encounters is the clearest next step for understanding behaviour guidance and evaluating educational transfer.

This publication has 44 references indexed in Scilit: