From interpretation to consent: Arguments, beliefs and meaning
Author:
- 25 December 2011
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Discourse Studies
- Vol. 13 (6) , 806-814
Abstract
This article addresses the relationship between understanding and believing from the cognitive perspective of information-processing. I promote, within the scope of the Critical Discourse Analysis agenda, the relevance of an account of belief-fixation sustained by a combination of argumentative and cognitive insights. To this end, I first argue that discursive strategies fulfilling legitimization purposes, such as evidentials (see Hart, this issue), tap into the same cognitive mechanisms as (both sound and fallacious) arguments. I then proceed to examine the idea that the most effective arguments are the ones that manage to obscure or make irrelevant counter-evidence and propose, from a cognitive pragmatic perspective, a formulation of rhetorical effectiveness as a constraint on information-selection taking place at the interpretation stage and decisively influencing the evaluation stage responsible for belief-fixation.Keywords
This publication has 18 references indexed in Scilit:
- Constraining Context2011
- On combining pragma-dialectics with critical discourse analysis2011
- Epistemic VigilanceMind & Language, 2010
- Defining Manipulative Discourse: The Pragmatics of Cognitive IllusionsInternational Review of Pragmatics, 2009
- Procedural pragmatics and the study of discourse2007
- Discourse and manipulationDiscourse & Society, 2006
- Discourse, context and cognitionDiscourse Studies, 2006
- The role of misused concepts in manufacturing consent2005
- Missing links in mainstream CDA2005
- An Evolutionary Perspective on Testimony and ArgumentationPhilosophical Topics, 2001