The patient perspective in benign foregut surgery guidelines: bridging evidence, values, and clinical decision-making
Authors:
- 15 October 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Surgical Endoscopy
- p. 1-24
Abstract
Background Patient values influence preference-sensitive decisions in benign foregut (upper gastrointestinal) surgery, but their incorporation into guideline development is unclear. This systematic review evaluated how patient perspectives are included in clinical practice guidelines (CPGs) and whether involvement is associated with quality. Methods Databases and society websites were searched for CPGs addressing endoscopic or surgical management of benign foregut disease from January 2010 to March 2026. Two reviewers screened records, extracted data, mapped involvement across the 10-stage Armstrong framework, and assessed quality using AGREE II. Results Twenty-six CPGs were included. All used evidence-grading methods, but only 8 (31%) reported direct patient involvement. Six additional CPGs (23%) considered patient values indirectly through literature review and clinician assumptions. No CPG published before 2018 reported direct involvement. Among patient-involved CPGs, engagement most often occurred during recommendation development (8/8), evidence interpretation (5/8), and question or outcome formulation (5/8). None reported patient involvement in dissemination, implementation, updating, or evaluation of engagement. Later publication year was associated with direct involvement (OR 1.54 per year). In unadjusted analyses patient-involved CPGs had higher AGREE II scores for clarity, applicability, and editorial independence, but this did not remain statistically significant in sensitivity analyses restricting publication year and methodologist involvement. Conclusions Direct patient involvement remains uncommon and concentrated in recommendation development rather than the entirety of guideline development. Foregut-related surgical societies should combine patient-preference evidence with transparently reported patient partnership from priority setting through implementation and updating. Graphical abstractKeywords
This publication has 61 references indexed in Scilit:
- Process for quality assessment review of societal guidelines—an editorial to accompany “multi-society consensus conference and guideline on the treatment of gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD)”Surgical Endoscopy, 2022
- Multi-society consensus conference and guideline on the treatment of gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD)Surgical Endoscopy, 2022
- UEG and EAES rapid guideline: Update systematic review, network meta‐analysis, CINeMA and GRADE assessment, and evidence‐informed European recommendations on surgical management of GERDUnited European Gastroenterology Journal, 2022
- How to Interpret and Use a Clinical Practice Guideline or RecommendationJAMA, 2021
- SAGES guidelines for the surgical treatment of gastroesophageal reflux (GERD)Surgical Endoscopy, 2021
- SAGES guidelines for the use of peroral endoscopic myotomy (POEM) for the treatment of achalasiaSurgical Endoscopy, 2021
- Evaluation of Industry Relationships Among Authors of Clinical Practice Guidelines in GastroenterologyJAMA Internal Medicine, 2018
- Guidelines for the management of hiatal herniaSurgical Endoscopy, 2013
- SAGES guidelines for the surgical treatment of esophageal achalasiaSurgical Endoscopy, 2011
- Guidelines for surgical treatment of gastroesophageal reflux diseaseSurgical Endoscopy, 2010