A Unified Theory and Bayesian Framework for Phenological Inference from Biocollection Data: Resolving Paradoxes by Considering Phenophase Duration
Preprint
Abstract
Summary: Phenology, the study of recurring biological events, has gained increased attention with the rise of digitized biocollections. However, no general theoretical framework has linked variation in biocollection data to underlying phenological processes. We present a unified statistical theory of phenological distributions that mathematically integrates phenological extremes, onset timing, phenophase duration, cessation, and peak activity and links these phenomena to variation in biocollection data. A key insight from this theory is that phenological sensitivity estimates from biocollection data are confounded by phenophase duration. Both onset and duration contribute to variation in collection dates, and standard regression methods cannot disentangle these effects. To address this, we develop a Bayesian inference framework based on Gaussian processes (GPs) that explicitly models onset and duration as latent variables. We assess its performance under various scenarios, including model misspecification and identifiability, and show that it outperforms three alternative methods. Applying the method to an empirical dataset of over 5,000 herbarium records, we find that phenophase duration frequently acts as a confounder, correlating with one or more covariates across all species examined. These results highlight that phenophase duration is a critical but underappreciated factor in phenological studies using biocollection data.Keywords
This publication has 97 references indexed in Scilit:
- Warm Spring Days are Related to Shorter Durations of Reproductive Phenophases for Understory Forest HerbsEcology and Evolution, 2024
- Shifts in flowering phenology in response to spring temperatures in eastern TennesseeAmerican Journal of Botany, 2023
- Estimating phenology and phenological shifts with hierarchical modelingEcology, 2023
- Conceptual and practical issues limit the utility of statistical estimators of phenological eventsEcosphere, 2021
- Climate data and flowering times for 450 species from 1844 deepen the record of phenological change in southern GermanyAmerican Journal of Botany, 2021
- The USA National Phenology Network: Big Idea, Productivity, and Potential—and Now, at Big RiskThe Bulletin of the Ecological Society of America, 2020
- Patterns and biases in an Arctic herbarium specimen collection: Implications for phenological researchApplications in Plant Sciences, 2019
- A new method and insights for estimating phenological events from herbarium specimensApplications in Plant Sciences, 2019
- Detrending phenological time series improves climate–phenology analyses and reveals evidence of plasticityEcology, 2017
- Outlier Analysis2017