Optimizing Territorial Healthcare Networks with a Capacity-Constrained Hub-And-Spoke Allocation Algorithm: The Province of L’Aquila Case Study
Authors:
- Edoardo TrebbiETEdoardo Trebbi
- Tommaso BarlattaniTBTommaso Barlattani
- Antony BolognaABAntony Bologna
- Livia TognacciniLTLivia Tognaccini
- Alessandro SiliASAlessandro Sili
- Giuseppe Di MartinoGiuseppe Di Martino
- Cristinel StanCSCristinel Stan
- Camillo OdioCOCamillo Odio
- Tommaso StanisciaTommaso Staniscia
- Francesca PacittiFPFrancesca Pacitti
- Ferdinando RomanoFRFerdinando Romano
Open Access
- 1 April 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by MDPI AG in Healthcare
- Vol. 14 (7) , 915
Abstract
Background: Geographic and demographic disparities strongly influence access to community-based healthcare, especially in rural and mountainous areas. In Italy, Ministerial Decree 77/2022 promotes a territorial reorganization based on networked care models, but practical tools for translating policy standards into operational catchment areas remain limited. Methods: We developed a transparent, data-driven allocation framework combining travel-time accessibility and population-based capacity constraints. A case study was conducted in the Province of L’Aquila, within Local Health Authority ASL 1 Avezzano–Sulmona–L’Aquila, a low-density mountainous area including 65 municipalities. Using official ISTAT data, including the 2021 national origin–destination road travel-time matrix, municipalities were allocated to 3 hub nodes and 8 spoke nodes. Population caps of 50,000 residents per hub and 40,000 per spoke were applied. Scenario analyses were performed under 20, 30, and 40 min travel-time thresholds. Results: Under the 30 min scenario, all municipalities were allocated, but the L’Aquila hub exceeded the capacity cap. A cap-compliant 30 min allocation eliminated this violation at the cost of longer upper-tail travel times. Under the 20 min scenario, only 54 municipalities were allocated, leaving 11 mountainous municipalities outside the threshold. Under the 40 min scenario, all municipalities were allocated without capacity violations. Conclusions: The proposed framework provides a reproducible approach for territorial healthcare planning and makes explicit the trade-off between accessibility and capacity compliance in hub-and-spoke network design, particularly in geographically complex mountain settings.Keywords
This publication has 41 references indexed in Scilit:
- Spatial Heterogeneities or Inequalities? Health Care Supply and Demand of the Older Population in ItalyApplied Spatial Analysis and Policy, 2025
- Scaling up integrated care: Can community hospitals be an answer? A multiple-case study from the Emilia-Romagna region in ItalyHealth Policy, 2024
- The 2022 community-based integrated care reform in Italy: From desiderata to implementationHealth Policy, 2023
- A Scenario-based optimization model to design a hub network for covid-19 medical equipment managementOperations Management Research, 2023
- The 2022 primary care reform in Italy: Improving continuity and reducing regional disparities?Health Policy, 2023
- A robust multi-objective model for healthcare resource management and location planning during pandemicsAnnals of Operations Research, 2022
- We Asked the Experts: The Role of Rural Hospitals in Achieving Equitable Surgical Access in Low‐Resourced SettingsWorld Journal of Surgery, 2021
- Location and reorganization problems: The Calabrian health care system caseEuropean Journal of Operational Research, 2016
- Multi-modal two-step floating catchment area analysis of primary health care accessibilityHealth & Place, 2016
- An enhanced two-step floating catchment area (E2SFCA) method for measuring spatial accessibility to primary care physiciansHealth & Place, 2009