One dataset, four meta-analyses: synthesising mean effects and heterogeneity within and among populations
Open Access
- 13 October 2026
- journal article
- Published by The Company of Biologists in Biology Open
- Vol. 15 (10)
Abstract
Ecological syntheses (meta-analyses) usually ask ‘what is the average effect?’ But many questions also depend on whether outcomes become more or less variable and whether effects are predictable across contexts. We show how one dataset can support a workflow that synthesises both mean effects and within-group variability while also separating heterogeneity among study-level effects from residual heterogeneity among effect sizes within studies. Using an organic versus conventional crop-yield dataset, we analyse mean effects with the log response ratio (lnRR; Model 1) and within-group variability with the log variability ratio (lnVR) and log coefficient of variation ratio (lnCVR; Model 2), all calculated from the same summary statistics (means, s.d.s. and sample sizes). We then use multilevel location–scale meta-regression to test whether fertiliser type shifts expected lnRR and lnVR/lnCVR effects (Models 3 and 4) and whether residual and study-level heterogeneity differ between contexts. These heterogeneity components respectively inform consistency among represented comparisons and transferability to a new study. Analysing mean effects, within-group variability and context-dependent heterogeneity together can provide a more informative description of ecological responses than focusing on average effects alone.Keywords
Funding Information
- Canada Excellence Research Chair (CERC-2022-00074)
- NSERC Discovery Grant (RGPIN-2025-04813)
- JSPS Overseas Research Fellowships
- University of Alberta
This publication has 51 references indexed in Scilit:
- Location‐scale models and cross validation to advance quantitative evidence synthesisEcology, 2026
- Ecological meta‐analyses often produce unwarranted resultsEcology, 2025
- Location‐scale models for meta‐analysisResearch Synthesis Methods, 2022
- The orchard plot: Cultivating a forest plot for use in ecology, evolution, and beyondResearch Synthesis Methods, 2020
- Revisiting and expanding the meta‐analysis of variation: The log coefficient of variation ratioResearch Synthesis Methods, 2020
- Heterogeneity of Striatal Dopamine Function in Schizophrenia: Meta-analysis of VarianceBiological Psychiatry, 2020
- Heterogeneity in ecological and evolutionary meta‐analyses: its magnitude and implicationsEcology, 2016
- Methodological issues and advances in biological meta-analysisEvolutionary Ecology, 2012
- ggplot2WIREs Computational Statistics, 2011
- Quantifying heterogeneity in a meta‐analysisStatistics in Medicine, 2002