Use of the Paired-Comparison Technique to Determine the Most Valued Qualities of the McMaster Medical Programme Admissions Process
Authors:
- M.L. MarrinMMM.L. Marrin
- K.A. McIntoshKMK.A. McIntosh
- D. KeaneDKD. Keane
- M.L. SchmuckMSM.L. Schmuck
- 1 June 2004
- journal article
- Published by Springer Nature in Advances in Health Sciences Education
- Vol. 9 (2) , 129-135
Abstract
The Undergraduate Medical Programme at McMasterUniversity selects students using acomprehensive set of tools. Attempts to modifythe selection process over many years have beenimpeded by an inability to reconcile verystrongly held views among stakeholders as tothe importance of the selection tools and,indeed, the very purposes of the admissionprocess. The objective of this study was toidentify key `qualities' of the selectionprocess and to measure their relativeimportance to admissions process assessors.Through a qualitative review of internalresearch documents, Medical ProgrammeAdmissions Committee meeting minutes, memos andaccreditation surveys eight qualities of theadmissions process were identified: validity,fairness, accessibility, comprehensiveness,affordability, legal defensibility,contribution to class diversity and the role ofthe process as a public statement of theProgramme's values. Faculty, students andcommunity admissions assessors were surveyed,by mail, using a paired-comparisons technique.The overall response rate was 58%. By a widemargin, all three groups of admissionsassessors valued validity and fairness mosthighly. The least valued qualities wereaffordability and the role of the process as astatement of our values. Possible applicationsof this approach to the admissions processdeliberations are discussed.Keywords
This publication has 6 references indexed in Scilit:
- Validity of Admissions Measures in Predicting Performance Outcomes: The Contribution of Cognitive and Non-Cognitive DimensionsTeaching and Learning in Medicine, 2002
- The structured interview as a tool for predicting premature withdrawal from medical schoolAustralian and New Zealand Journal of Medicine, 1992
- Correlating studentsʼ undergraduate science GPAs, their MCAT scores, and the academic caliber of their undergraduate colleges with their first-year academic performances across five classes at Dartmouth Medical SchoolAcademic Medicine, 1992
- The interview in the admission processAcademic Medicine, 1990
- Using a standardized-patient examination to establish the predictive validity of the MCAT and undergraduate GPA as admissions criteriaAcademic Medicine, 1989
- Techniques of attitude scale construction.1957