The Role of Leadership in the Success of Participatory Planning Processes
Author:
- 1 April 2009
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in European Urban and Regional Studies
- Vol. 16 (2) , 115-130
Abstract
The literature discusses how successful results in a participatory planning process can be achieved in localities with qualified social capital; that is, civil organizations and relationships built up within a community. Nevertheless, despite low-profile development figures and an inadequate number of civic associations (social capital),the Provincial Development Planning Process in Şanlıurfa (Turkey) was achieved by local stakeholders, who shared their views on the problems and potentials of the province and established a vision for the future. This study aims to examine the factors which lay behind the success of the participatory planning process in Şanlıurfa despite the lack of social capital.The leadership undertaken by powerful actors in the public sector can be said to have played the main role. The Provincial Development Planning Process was initiated and coordinated by the highest planning organization in the country, the State Planning Organization. In the case of Şanlıurfa, the planning process was coordinated jointly by a strong central-level public administration (South Eastern Anatolia Regional Development Administration) and the Şanlıurfa Governorship. This article claims that a participatory planning process can be realized in settlements with immature social capital, as in Şanlıurfa, if guided intensely by powerful institutions. However,this does not weaken the significance of social capital, as the participation of stakeholders in the planning process does not guarantee a successful implementation of the plan.The tradition of collective action (mature social capital) plays a crucial role in implementation. Moreover, for `bottom-up' processes (i.e. voluntary local development projects) social capital comes to the forefront as a significant factor.Keywords
This publication has 7 references indexed in Scilit:
- Centralized and decentralized tourism governance in TurkeyAnnals of Tourism Research, 2005
- Participatory development for regional sustainability in Western Australia: an enabling state?Local Environment, 2004
- Public Participation in Environmental Decision Making: Findings from Communities Facing Toxic Waste CleanupJournal of the American Planning Association, 2004
- Coping Strategies, Social Capital and SpaceEuropean Urban and Regional Studies, 2002
- Social Capital, Sustainability and Environmental PlanningPlanning Theory & Practice, 2001
- Planning Theory's Emerging Paradigm: Communicative Action and Interactive PracticeJournal of Planning Education and Research, 1995
- Institutional performance, political culture and political changeStudies in Comparative International Development, 1995