Cost-effectiveness thresholds: guiding health care spending for population health improvement

Authors:
  • PRPaul Revill
    Paul Revill
  • JOJessica Ochalek
    Jessica Ochalek
  • JLJames Lomas
    James Lomas
  • RNRyota Nakamura
    Ryota Nakamura
  • BWBeth Woods
    Beth Woods
  • ARAlex Rollinger
    Alex Rollinger
  • MSMarc Suhrcke
    Marc Suhrcke
  • MSMark Sculpher
    Mark Sculpher
  • KCKarl Claxton
    Karl Claxton

Abstract
In the first phase of iDSI (2014-2016), Methods Working Groups were established to investigate three areas of economic evaluation for which additional methods guidance for analysts and policymakers in low- and middle income countries was deemed particularly valuable. These linked directly to specific Principles for the practice of economic evaluation detailed in the iDSI Reference Case. This iDSI Methods Working Group report details the findings from the investigation into cost-effectiveness thresholds (CETs) for economic evaluation - linked to Principle 10: Impact on Other Constraints and Budget Impact – “The impact of implementing the intervention on the health budget and on other constraints should be identified clearly and separately”. The authors offer a guide for policymakers, budget holders and analysts on CET conceptualisation, and the assumptions and implications of these conceptualisations. They provide estimates of CETs that can be used in applied studies in a wide range of jurisdictions, for different kinds of decisions. They argue that all those whose decisions have implications for healthcare resource allocation in low- and middle-income countries should carefully consider the other claims on limited resources as well as their likely opportunity costs when informing or making resource allocation decisions.