Meta-analytic evaluation of the hypotensive effect of renal denervation in models of renovascular hypertension

Authors:

Abstract
Hypertension caused by impaired renal blood supply accounts for approximately 1–5 % of all cases of arterial hypertension (HTN). The aim of this study was to evaluate the effect of renal denervation (RD) on hypertension development in the “2 kidneys, 1 clamp” model, the “1 kidney, 1 clamp” model, the 5/6 nephrectomy (NE), and the aortic coarctation model. Design and methods . We selected 16 studies for meta-analysis. These studies examined RD effect on hemodynamic parameters in animal models “2 kidneys, 1 clamp”: 14 studies used total ischemic kidney denervation (IKD), 4 studies used afferent IKD, 2 studies used non-ischemic kidney denervation (NIKD), and 2 studies used total denervation of both kidneys. In addition, RD effect was studied in the “1 kidney, 1 clamp” model in 4 studies, in the 5/6 NE model in 4 studies, and in the aortic coarctation model in 2 studies. Results . A meta-analysis showed that in the “2 kidneys, 1 clamp” model, total and afferent IKD effectively decrease baseline blood pressure (BP) and prevent the development of hypertension. The change in BP after total IKD was −11,7 [−19,6, −8,4] % and after afferent IKD −15,9 [−19,8, −9,8] %. Total IKD also reduced the level of angiotensin II in plasma (the change was −107,1 [−143,6, −70,7] pg/ml). No decrease in the “white coat syndrome” was found after IKD. NIKD had no effect on BP level. After total RD BP changes comprised −8,1 [−16,8, 1,3] % in the “1 kidney, 1 clamp” model, −16,7 [−17,3, −10,9] % in the 5/6 NE model, and −16,3 [−18,1, −13,8] % in the aortic coarctation model. Conclusions . A meta-analysis showed that in the “2 kidneys, 1 clamp” model, total and afferent IKD effectively reduce baseline BP and prevent the development of hypertension. The hypotensive effect of IKD is explained, among other things, by a decrease in Ang2 levels. RD effects in animals with “2 kidneys, 1 clamp” hypertension have been well studied, while other models have been studied to a much lesser extent.

This publication has 37 references indexed in Scilit: