What we miss shapes what we protect: sea turtles as a case study of grey literature and language bias in an evidence synthesis
Authors:
- Harris W.K. HengHHHarris W.K. Heng
- Kristine C.V. BuenafeKBKristine C.V. Buenafe
- Jaime RestrepoJRJaime Restrepo
- Dina NistharDNDina Nisthar
- Tatsuya AmanoTATatsuya Amano
- Nicolas PilcherNPNicolas Pilcher
- Nguyen Trong DucNDNguyen Trong Duc
- Chia-Ling FongCFChia-Ling Fong
- Sekar M.C. HerandarudewiSHSekar M.C. Herandarudewi
- Daphne Z. HohDHDaphne Z. Hoh
Preprint
Abstract
Evidence-based approaches are increasingly advocated and applied in conservation to provide reliable recommendations for management and policymaking. Although substantial efforts have been undertaken to generate ecological knowledge across languages and publication types, many syntheses and meta-analyses fail to include relevant literature sources; drawing into question their reliability. To assess the extent of biases resulting from ignoring grey literature and non-English publications, we reviewed and synthesised movement and migratory connectivity data for green turtles across Southeast Asia from multiple literature types and eight languages. We identified substantial losses in connectivity information, with at least half of all locations losing more than 88% of their connections, and shifts in demographic representation and sampling techniques when grey literature was excluded from the evidence base. The exclusion of non-English literature had a comparatively smaller impact. The regional connectivity network generated through this study highlights the need for holistic reviews to develop evidence bases to underpin transboundary management of migratory species. Ignoring grey literature and, potentially, regional languages in the development may lead to misallocation of limited management resources. Holistic reviews can further support the establishment of Important Areas for migratory species and inform how we meet and report on global biodiversity commitments.Keywords
This publication has 76 references indexed in Scilit:
- How multilingual is scholarly communication? Mapping the global distribution of languages in publications and citationsJournal of the Association for Information Science and Technology, 2026
- Seascape connectivity shapes fish functional diversity, ecosystem functioning and resilience in subtropical coral reefsCoral Reefs, 2025
- Language inclusion in ecological systematic reviews and maps: Barriers and perspectivesResearch Synthesis Methods, 2024
- Satellite tagging and flipper tag recoveries reveal migration patterns and foraging distribution of loggerhead sea turtles (Caretta caretta) from eastern AustraliaMarine Biology, 2022
- Mapping citizen science contributions to the UN sustainable development goalsSustainability Science, 2020
- Top 100 research questions for biodiversity conservation in Southeast AsiaBiological Conservation, 2019
- The database of the PREDICTS (Projecting Responses of Ecological Diversity In Changing Terrestrial Systems) projectEcology and Evolution, 2016
- Shades of grey: Two forms of grey literature important for reviews in conservationBiological Conservation, 2015
- Migratory marine species: their status, threats and conservation management needsAquatic Conservation: Marine and Freshwater Ecosystems, 2014
- Information retrieval for ecological synthesesResearch Synthesis Methods, 2014