Adequacy of Timber Trespass Civil Awards: A Louisiana Case Study
- 7 October 2019
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Forestry
- Vol. 117 (6) , 533-542
Abstract
Timber trespass in Louisiana is a civil offense punishable by restitution of three times the timber’s current market value, yet whether this compensation level alone is adequate at present is unclear. We modeled a loblolly pine plantation across a range of site qualities in Louisiana. First, we estimated financial returns from a traditional sawtimber rotation using historical state timber prices that included three harvests: two thinnings and a final cut; harvest times differed by site quality. We then assumed all timber was taken at the first thinning. Net present value (NPV) determined appropriateness of compensation at 1×, 2×, and 3× stumpage revenues and was compared to the traditional rotation’s NPV. The NPVs were calculated with and without additional settlement for reforestation costs. We concluded that reforestation costs in addition to 3× stumpage value reimbursement were required to negate the effect of timber prices and better the traditional rotation’s NPV.Keywords
This publication has 4 references indexed in Scilit:
- WILLINGNESS TO PAY FOR POTENTIAL STANDING TIMBER INSURANCEJournal of Agricultural and Applied Economics, 2015
- Assessing and Understanding Timber Trespass and Theft Laws in the Appalachian RegionNorthern Journal of Applied Forestry, 2005
- Taking the forest: The shared meaning of tree theftSociety & Natural Resources, 1998
- Stand Density Management Diagram for Loblolly Pine Plantations in North LouisianaSouthern Journal of Applied Forestry, 1994