Point Counterpoint: The Function of Contradictions on an Interdisciplinary Health Care Team
- 1 March 2008
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Qualitative Health Research
- Vol. 18 (3) , 369-379
Abstract
In this qualitative study we used Dialectical Theory to analyze contradictions occurring between medical doctors (MDs) and nurse practitioners (NPs) working collaboratively on a health care team. The analysis of interview data revealed contradictions in two areas: (1) NPs espouse a need for heightened autonomy in their working associations with medical doctors, whereas conversely, MDs emphasize a need for ongoing connection, and (2) MDs argue that NPs should be more proactive problem solvers and frame their working relationships as educational. However, NPs argue that MDs enact patterns of behavior that limit proactive problem solving and curtail the educational potential of those relationships, thus reinforcing predictable work routines. Both areas of contradiction constitute what dialectical theorist Leslie Baxter refers to as “oppositions.” Examples of these oppositions are provided in the analysis. The study concludes with an assessment of how such contradictions might constitute developmental opportunities for NPs and MDs working in collaboration.Keywords
This publication has 20 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Collaborative Healthcare Team: Tensive Issues Warranting Ongoing ConsiderationJournal of the American Academy of Nurse Practitioners, 2005
- Relationships as dialoguesPersonal Relationships, 2004
- Couple Perceptions of Their Similarities and Differences: A Dialectical PerspectiveJournal of Social and Personal Relationships, 2003
- Perceptions of Dialectical Contradictions in Turning Points of Development in Heterosexual Romantic RelationshipsJournal of Social and Personal Relationships, 1999
- The Acute Care Nurse Practitioner in Collaborative PracticeJournal of the American Academy of Nurse Practitioners, 1996
- Two explanations of nurse practitioner interactions and participatory decision making with physiciansResearch in Nursing & Health, 1991
- Survey of Geriatric Nurse Practitioners in the West: Scope of Practice and EffectivenessJournal of the American Academy of Nurse Practitioners, 1990
- Dialectical Contradictions in Relationship DevelopmentJournal of Social and Personal Relationships, 1990
- Clinical Nurse Specialist Collaboration with PhysiciansClinical Nurse Specialist, 1990
- Collaboration Between Nurses and PhysiciansImage: the Journal of Nursing Scholarship, 1988