Sustainable financing is critical for ensuring equitable access to eye health services, particularly in low- and middle-income countries where donor dependency is high. This study examines the sustainability and welfare impact of eye health financing using the Noor Dubai Foundation (NDF) intervention in Katsina State, Nigeria. A qualitative research design was adopted, utilizing Key Informant Interviews (KIIs), Focus Group Discussions (FGDs), and facility assessments across selected health facilities. Findings indicate that the NDF intervention significantly improved access to cataract surgeries and related eye care services by eliminating financial barriers. Quantitative valuation of services reveals that beneficiaries received substantial implicit financial transfers, with an estimated mean value of ₦132,500. Poverty impact simulations show that the intervention effectively increased beneficiaries’ income above the international poverty threshold. Further analysis using the Poverty Gap Index (PGI) demonstrates complete elimination of poverty intensity among beneficiaries post-intervention. A quasi-experimental Difference-in-Differences (DiD) framework confirms that welfare gains are directly attributable to the intervention. The findings highlight the role of health financing as a poverty reduction instrument and the risks associated with donor withdrawal. The study recommends integrating eye health financing into public health systems and expanding universal health coverage to sustain these gains.