Strengthening the quality of qualitative models: a quality framework for future-oriented sustainability research
Open Access
- 4 December 2025
- journal article
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Sustainability
- Vol. 6
Abstract
Alternative Economic Models (AEMs) are theoretical frameworks that, if implemented, could fundamentally transform economic systems by aligning financial objectives with sustainability goals. Conducting rigorous research on future-oriented AEMs and other complex sustainability systems presents challenges, particularly due to the exploration of largely unverifiable future possibilities. Qualitative models can enhance the completeness, insights, and communications of such research. However, the absence of comprehensive guidelines for ensuring and assessing the quality of future-oriented qualitative models raises concerns about their reliability. The aim of this paper is to improve the quality of qualitative models used in future- and sustainability-focused AEM research by defining three key aspects of model quality: (1) scientific validity; (2) scientific usefulness; and (3) practical usefulness. Drawing on diverse fields, including futures studies, modeling methodologies, and the philosophy of science, we identify 11 Model Quality Considerations (MQCs). These MQCs are tested and refined through two AEM model case applications. We propose a framework for model developers and evaluators to understand their roles and the interactions among MQCs. Our analysis reveals that some MQCs are inherently incompatible, making it impractical to fully satisfy all considerations in a single model. Instead, developing high-quality models requires strategically prioritizing quality aspects, based on the model’s intended purpose. The paper concludes by outlining directions for future research.Keywords
This publication has 51 references indexed in Scilit:
- Environmental principles for modern sustainable economic frameworks including the circular economySustainability Science, 2022
- Endangering the integrity of science by misusing unvalidated models and untested assumptions as facts: General considerations and the mineral and phosphorus scarcity fallacySustainability Science, 2021
- Seeds of good anthropocenes: developing sustainability scenarios for Northern EuropeSustainability Science, 2019
- Three pillars of sustainability: in search of conceptual originsSustainability Science, 2018
- Testing the consistency between goals and policies for sustainable development: mental models of how the world works today are inconsistent with mental models of how the world will work in the futureSustainability Science, 2016
- Why We Cannot Learn from Minimal ModelsErkenntnis, 2015
- Learning from Minimal Economic ModelsErkenntnis, 2008
- Model validation in soft systems practiceSystems Research, 1995
- System Design Modeling and Metamodeling1991
- But is it rigorous? Trustworthiness and authenticity in naturalistic evaluationNew Directions for Program Evaluation, 1986